Skip to content
  • About
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Book
  • Careers
  • Podcast
  • Recommended
  • Speaking
  • All
  • Physician
  • Practice
  • Policy
  • Finance
  • Conditions
  • .edu
  • Patient
  • Meds
  • Tech
  • Social
  • Video
    • All
    • Physician
    • Practice
    • Policy
    • Finance
    • Conditions
    • .edu
    • Patient
    • Meds
    • Tech
    • Social
    • Video
    • About
    • Contact
    • Contribute
    • Book
    • Careers
    • Podcast
    • Recommended
    • Speaking

The goal of medicine is to balance evidence with stories

Paul Marantz, MD, MPH
Education
November 6, 2014
Share
Tweet
Share

Recently, Dr. Peter Kramer published an intriguing, well-written, but poorly reasoned and potentially dangerous “thought piece” in the New York Times. His article, “Why Doctors Need Stories,” contains several logical flaws and erroneous arguments, but the overarching concept is a classic straw man argument.

He creates a false and highly misleading notion of what evidence-based medicine (EBM) is and then proceeds with a screed against EBM in order to extol the virtue of the anecdote. This sort of argument works particularly well when the reader has little or no knowledge of the term being misrepresented, so I expect it’s been quite effective even with the generally well-informed Times readership, who wouldn’t be expected to know what EBM is.

Understanding evidence-based medicine

So let’s start with what Kramer says about EBM in his piece. He notes that his preferred approach, “giving weight to the combination of doctors’ experience and biological plausibility, stands somewhat in conflict with the principles of evidence-based medicine. The [EBM] movement’s manifesto, published in the Journal of the American Medical Association in 1992, proclaimed a new era that would see near-exclusive reliance on systematic clinical research—the direct assessment of treatments in patients.”

Kramer allows himself some wiggle room by saying “somewhat” and adding “near” to “exclusive reliance,” but the point is crystal clear: these doctrinaire EBMers, manifesto in hand, are preventing us warm and caring docs from talking with our patients, forcing us into a mindless and soulless practice of cookbook medicine wherein we follow protocols and algorithms and ignore the heartfelt pleas of our patients seeking succor and support. If only doctors were trained to listen to their patients, to understand the power of stories, we’d all be happier and healthier.

But he’s creating a false premise to explode. First, what is this “manifesto”? Since Kramer refers to something published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) in 1992, I presume he means “Evidence-Based Medicine: A New Approach to Teaching the Practice of Medicine.” This, and the series of “Users’ Guides to the Medical Literature” subsequently published in JAMA (then in book form and now on the Web), can hardly be considered “manifestos” (at least, not as the sort of doctrinaire rulebooks the word usually implies). (Helpful note: I keep my copy of Marx on a different shelf of my bookcase from the one where I keep my “Users’ Guides” to avoid just such confusion.)

Looking at this “manifesto,” I found it almost amusing to see what the authors wrote 22 years ago in describing how wrong-headed doctors make false arguments against EBM: “Misinterpretation 1. — Evidence-based medicine ignores clinical experience and clinical intuition.” (Straw man, anyone?)

Now let’s look at what EBM really is. As defined nearly 20 years ago by David Sackett, one of the founders of this discipline: “Evidence based medicine is the conscientious, explicit, and judicious use of current best evidence in making decisions about the care of individual patients. The practice of evidence based medicine means integrating individual clinical expertise with the best available external clinical evidence from systematic research.”

Patients’ stories — case histories — are evidence. All of the EBM “manifestos” acknowledge that, and case reports have always been part of the EBM landscape. (Indeed, my own first publication was a case report.) But there is an important caveat: case studies (and patients’ stories) are weaker evidence than carefully designed and conducted (and appropriately interpreted) research studies. There is a hierarchy of evidence, and case reports are at the lowest level of that hierarchy. There are excellent reasons for this, but that’s a separate discussion.

The role of narrative medicine

The persuasive power of the piece is enhanced by the image of the lone wolf crying out for justice in an unjust world: “I have long felt isolated in this position, embracing stories.” Nice image, but a quick look at the world around him would have shown Dr. Kramer that he is not alone. Indeed, the growth of what has come to be known as “narrative medicine” began in the 1990s, paralleling (and perhaps partly in response to) the development of EBM. Now, in my opinion, the valuing of stories overevidence is highly dangerous, and if you’re looking for acolytes rather than scientists, you’re more likely to find them preaching narrative medicine than practicing EBM … But look at me: Kramer has got me mirroring his false dichotomy.

Any good doctor knows that both listening to stories (in the context of clinical experience and good judgment) and applying research studies (judiciously and competently) are required to practice medicine. Caring for patients using one without the other is a fool’s errand. (And by the way: my medical school, like most medical schools, puts a lot of effort into teaching communication skills — including through “narrative medicine” — to its students.) Blending the two approaches effectively and seamlessly isn’t easy, but the goal of medical education — and doctoring — is to strike the right balance.

Paul Marantz is associate dean, clinical research education and director, Center for Public Health Sciences, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, NY. He blogs at The Doctor’s Tablet.

ADVERTISEMENT

Prev

Can surgery residency programs be ranked?

November 6, 2014 Kevin 3
…
Next

Medicare punishes hospitals for taking care of poor people

November 6, 2014 Kevin 7
…

Tagged as: Medical school

Post navigation

< Previous Post
Can surgery residency programs be ranked?
Next Post >
Medicare punishes hospitals for taking care of poor people

ADVERTISEMENT

More by Paul Marantz, MD, MPH

  • Why we must be cautious about hydroxychloroquine

    Paul Marantz, MD, MPH
  • Multiple choice tests in our post-truth world

    Paul Marantz, MD, MPH
  • More guns or fewer? The problems with evidence-based gun research

    Paul Marantz, MD, MPH

Related Posts

  • Why medical writing is essential to medicine

    Steven Zhang, MD
  • The difference between learning medicine and doing medicine

    Steven Zhang, MD
  • Considering the recent setbacks of evidence-based medicine

    Kenneth Lin, MD
  • Why medical students should be taught the business side of medicine

    Martinus Megalla
  • How social media can advance humanism in medicine

    Pooja Lakshmin, MD
  • Why this medical student chose to pursue medicine

    Ton La, Jr., MD, JD

More in Education

  • Why medical student debt is killing primary care in America

    Alexander Camp
  • Why the pre-med path is pushing future doctors to the brink

    Jordan Williamson, MEd
  • Graduating from medical school without family: a story of strength and survival

    Anonymous
  • 2 hours to decide my future: Why the NRMP’s SOAP process is broken

    Nicolette V. S. Sewall, MD, MPH
  • What led me from nurse practitioner to medical school

    Sarah White, APRN
  • Bridging the rural surgical care gap with rotating health care teams

    Ankit Jain
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • Why are medical students turning away from primary care? [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Here’s what providers really need in a modern EHR

      Laura Kohlhagen, MD, MBA | Tech
    • Why “do no harm” might be harming modern medicine

      Sabooh S. Mubbashar, MD | Physician
    • How community paramedicine impacts Indigenous elders

      Noah Weinberg | Conditions
    • Addressing U.S. vaccine inequities in vulnerable communities [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • How to speak the language of leadership to improve doctor wellness [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
  • Past 6 Months

    • Why tracking cognitive load could save doctors and patients

      Hiba Fatima Hamid | Education
    • Why are medical students turning away from primary care? [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Why “do no harm” might be harming modern medicine

      Sabooh S. Mubbashar, MD | Physician
    • Here’s what providers really need in a modern EHR

      Laura Kohlhagen, MD, MBA | Tech
    • What the world must learn from the life and death of Hind Rajab

      Saba Qaiser, RN | Conditions
    • How medical culture hides burnout in plain sight

      Marco Benítez | Conditions
  • Recent Posts

    • Addressing U.S. vaccine inequities in vulnerable communities [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Why Canada is losing its skilled immigrant doctors

      Olumuyiwa Bamgbade, MD | Physician
    • Why doctors are reclaiming control from burnout culture

      Maureen Gibbons, MD | Physician
    • Would The Pitts’ Dr. Robby Robinavitch welcome a new colleague? Yes. Especially if their initials were AI.

      Gabe Jones, MBA | Tech
    • Why medicine must stop worshipping burnout and start valuing humanity

      Sarah White, APRN | Conditions
    • Why screening for diseases you might have can backfire

      Andy Lazris, MD and Alan Roth, DO | Physician

Subscribe to KevinMD and never miss a story!

Get free updates delivered free to your inbox.


Find jobs at
Careers by KevinMD.com

Search thousands of physician, PA, NP, and CRNA jobs now.

Learn more

View 1 Comments >

Founded in 2004 by Kevin Pho, MD, KevinMD.com is the web’s leading platform where physicians, advanced practitioners, nurses, medical students, and patients share their insight and tell their stories.

Social

  • Like on Facebook
  • Follow on Twitter
  • Connect on Linkedin
  • Subscribe on Youtube
  • Instagram

ADVERTISEMENT

  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • Why are medical students turning away from primary care? [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Here’s what providers really need in a modern EHR

      Laura Kohlhagen, MD, MBA | Tech
    • Why “do no harm” might be harming modern medicine

      Sabooh S. Mubbashar, MD | Physician
    • How community paramedicine impacts Indigenous elders

      Noah Weinberg | Conditions
    • Addressing U.S. vaccine inequities in vulnerable communities [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • How to speak the language of leadership to improve doctor wellness [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
  • Past 6 Months

    • Why tracking cognitive load could save doctors and patients

      Hiba Fatima Hamid | Education
    • Why are medical students turning away from primary care? [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Why “do no harm” might be harming modern medicine

      Sabooh S. Mubbashar, MD | Physician
    • Here’s what providers really need in a modern EHR

      Laura Kohlhagen, MD, MBA | Tech
    • What the world must learn from the life and death of Hind Rajab

      Saba Qaiser, RN | Conditions
    • How medical culture hides burnout in plain sight

      Marco Benítez | Conditions
  • Recent Posts

    • Addressing U.S. vaccine inequities in vulnerable communities [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Why Canada is losing its skilled immigrant doctors

      Olumuyiwa Bamgbade, MD | Physician
    • Why doctors are reclaiming control from burnout culture

      Maureen Gibbons, MD | Physician
    • Would The Pitts’ Dr. Robby Robinavitch welcome a new colleague? Yes. Especially if their initials were AI.

      Gabe Jones, MBA | Tech
    • Why medicine must stop worshipping burnout and start valuing humanity

      Sarah White, APRN | Conditions
    • Why screening for diseases you might have can backfire

      Andy Lazris, MD and Alan Roth, DO | Physician

MedPage Today Professional

An Everyday Health Property Medpage Today
  • Terms of Use | Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
All Content © KevinMD, LLC
Site by Outthink Group

The goal of medicine is to balance evidence with stories
1 comments

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

Loading Comments...