Skip to content
  • About
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Book
  • Careers
  • Podcast
  • Recommended
  • Speaking
  • All
  • Physician
  • Practice
  • Policy
  • Finance
  • Conditions
  • .edu
  • Patient
  • Meds
  • Tech
  • Social
  • Video
    • All
    • Physician
    • Practice
    • Policy
    • Finance
    • Conditions
    • .edu
    • Patient
    • Meds
    • Tech
    • Social
    • Video
    • About
    • Contact
    • Contribute
    • Book
    • Careers
    • Podcast
    • Recommended
    • Speaking

The economic case against the death penalty

Allen Frances, MD
Physician
July 17, 2014
Share
Tweet
Share

I am not strongly against the death penalty on principle or on moral grounds — assuming, of course, that it could somehow be narrowly and efficiently restricted to a very few egregiously deserving and certainly guilty criminals.

I don’t even find it particularly appalling (or cruel and unusual) punishment that a killer may have some few minutes of physical discomfort before expiring during a clumsily administered execution. My experience as a doctor teaches that dying is never that much fun, and I don’t see why a heinous criminal should expect a completely free terminal ride when this is not guaranteed to any of the rest of us.

But I do have a very strong objection to the death penalty based purely on practical economic grounds. Killing criminals, whether they deserve it or not, simply costs much more than our society can afford and provides far too little value in return.

Recently, I have appeared as an expert witness in two death penalty cases. Both trials dragged on for many months, produced thousands of pages of documentation, and engaged hundreds of witnesses — including a a platoon of experts arguing for each side.

There seemed to be a limitless budget with no attention to time or money. The stakes are so high in death penalty cases that every procedural nicety must be given its fullest possible due. Judges are extremely concerned about being reversed on a technicality by the appeals courts. This would be embarrassing to them and require a lengthy and expensive retrial. The safest way for a judge to achieve an appeal proof verdict is always to allow the defense the greatest possible leeway. This encourages defense lawyers to pose every possible objection and to weave every conceivable mitigating theory (however outlandish) hoping that, with enough stuff out there, something may stick with the jury or later with the courts of appeal. The fact that defense lawyers are on the clock (getting hefty hourly fees, usually supported by tax dollars) also provides them with a strong financial incentive to drag things out as long as possible.

Our adversarial legal process encourages an unenlightened and dispiriting dueling of expert witnesses. Their opinions are usually tailored to exaggerate the case for one side or the other — rather than seeking a truth that usually lies somewhere in between. Often enough, the expert seems to be little little more than a pliable hired gun.

And what is society’s reward for all this effort and expense? Precious little. In many states and in federal cases, the death penalty has become purely symbolic. Though offenders are sometimes sentenced to death, they usually wind up never getting executed; instead they live for decades in expensive death row cells. And in the states committed to actually following through on the death penalty, there is no evidence that executions have any more deterrent value than life without parole.

The price tag for the death penalty can reach tens of millions of dollars in any given case. Since budgets are always ultimately a zero-sum game, wouldn’t justice be better served and money better spent doing things that might actually reduce crime?

Increasingly, the death penalty has become an anomaly and an embarrassment. Already, 140 countries have eliminated it and the biggest sponsors are China, Iran and us. We are also in the bad company of an assortment of the more dubious Middle Eastern, African and Asian countries.

Only a few and weak arguments can be raised to support the death penalty — that it provides society with an opportunity to inflict just retribution, has an impact on deterrence, promotes a sense of closure for survivors, and is a bargaining chip to encourage criminals to confess and cop a plea.

Even if you buy into some or all of this, the exorbitant financial cost of the death penalty makes it unsupportable as public policy. And you also have to factor in the haunting possibility that the state may sometimes kill an innocent man.

Allen Frances is a psychiatrist and professor emeritus, Duke University.  He blogs at the Huffington Post.

Prev

Perfection fuels physician burnout

July 17, 2014 Kevin 13
…
Next

Cost-effective diagnosis was the only option

July 17, 2014 Kevin 3
…

ADVERTISEMENT

Tagged as: Psychiatry

Post navigation

< Previous Post
Perfection fuels physician burnout
Next Post >
Cost-effective diagnosis was the only option

ADVERTISEMENT

More by Allen Frances, MD

  • #MeToo shows why women must learn sexual self-defense

    Allen Frances, MD
  • The problem of polypharmacy in psychiatry

    Allen Frances, MD
  • Pay primary care doctors what they’re worth

    Allen Frances, MD

More in Physician

  • The unspoken contract between doctors and patients explained

    Matthew G. Checketts, DO
  • The truth in medicine: Why connection matters most

    Ryan Nadelson, MD
  • New student loan caps could shut low-income students out of medicine

    Tom Phan, MD
  • Why “the best physicians” risk burnout and isolation

    Scott Abramson, MD
  • Why real medicine is more than quick labels

    Arthur Lazarus, MD, MBA
  • Limiting beliefs are holding your career back

    Sanj Katyal, MD
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • Why primary care doctors are drowning in debt despite saving lives

      John Wei, MD | Physician
    • How federal actions threaten vaccine policy and trust

      American College of Physicians | Conditions
    • Are we repeating the statin playbook with lipoprotein(a)?

      Larry Kaskel, MD | Conditions
    • mRNA post vaccination syndrome: Is it real?

      Harry Oken, MD | Conditions
    • Closing the diversity gap in Parkinson’s research

      Vicky Chan | Conditions
    • The unspoken contract between doctors and patients explained

      Matthew G. Checketts, DO | Physician
  • Past 6 Months

    • COVID-19 was real: a doctor’s frontline account

      Randall S. Fong, MD | Conditions
    • Why primary care doctors are drowning in debt despite saving lives

      John Wei, MD | Physician
    • Why so many doctors secretly feel like imposters

      Ryan Nadelson, MD | Physician
    • Confessions of a lipidologist in recovery: the infection we’ve ignored for 40 years

      Larry Kaskel, MD | Conditions
    • A physician employment agreement term that often tricks physicians

      Dennis Hursh, Esq | Finance
    • Why taxing remittances harms families and global health care

      Dalia Saha, MD | Finance
  • Recent Posts

    • The unspoken contract between doctors and patients explained

      Matthew G. Checketts, DO | Physician
    • AI isn’t hallucinating, it’s fabricating—and that’s a problem [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Brooklyn hepatitis C cluster reveals hidden dangers in outpatient clinics

      Don Weiss, MD, MPH | Policy
    • The truth in medicine: Why connection matters most

      Ryan Nadelson, MD | Physician
    • New student loan caps could shut low-income students out of medicine

      Tom Phan, MD | Physician
    • Why trust and simplicity matter more than buzzwords in hospital AI

      Rafael Rolon Rivera, MD | Tech

Subscribe to KevinMD and never miss a story!

Get free updates delivered free to your inbox.


Find jobs at
Careers by KevinMD.com

Search thousands of physician, PA, NP, and CRNA jobs now.

Learn more

View 3 Comments >

Founded in 2004 by Kevin Pho, MD, KevinMD.com is the web’s leading platform where physicians, advanced practitioners, nurses, medical students, and patients share their insight and tell their stories.

Social

  • Like on Facebook
  • Follow on Twitter
  • Connect on Linkedin
  • Subscribe on Youtube
  • Instagram

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • Why primary care doctors are drowning in debt despite saving lives

      John Wei, MD | Physician
    • How federal actions threaten vaccine policy and trust

      American College of Physicians | Conditions
    • Are we repeating the statin playbook with lipoprotein(a)?

      Larry Kaskel, MD | Conditions
    • mRNA post vaccination syndrome: Is it real?

      Harry Oken, MD | Conditions
    • Closing the diversity gap in Parkinson’s research

      Vicky Chan | Conditions
    • The unspoken contract between doctors and patients explained

      Matthew G. Checketts, DO | Physician
  • Past 6 Months

    • COVID-19 was real: a doctor’s frontline account

      Randall S. Fong, MD | Conditions
    • Why primary care doctors are drowning in debt despite saving lives

      John Wei, MD | Physician
    • Why so many doctors secretly feel like imposters

      Ryan Nadelson, MD | Physician
    • Confessions of a lipidologist in recovery: the infection we’ve ignored for 40 years

      Larry Kaskel, MD | Conditions
    • A physician employment agreement term that often tricks physicians

      Dennis Hursh, Esq | Finance
    • Why taxing remittances harms families and global health care

      Dalia Saha, MD | Finance
  • Recent Posts

    • The unspoken contract between doctors and patients explained

      Matthew G. Checketts, DO | Physician
    • AI isn’t hallucinating, it’s fabricating—and that’s a problem [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Brooklyn hepatitis C cluster reveals hidden dangers in outpatient clinics

      Don Weiss, MD, MPH | Policy
    • The truth in medicine: Why connection matters most

      Ryan Nadelson, MD | Physician
    • New student loan caps could shut low-income students out of medicine

      Tom Phan, MD | Physician
    • Why trust and simplicity matter more than buzzwords in hospital AI

      Rafael Rolon Rivera, MD | Tech

MedPage Today Professional

An Everyday Health Property Medpage Today
  • Terms of Use | Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
All Content © KevinMD, LLC
Site by Outthink Group

The economic case against the death penalty
3 comments

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

Loading Comments...