Skip to content
  • About
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Book
  • Careers
  • Podcast
  • Recommended
  • Speaking
  • All
  • Physician
  • Practice
  • Policy
  • Finance
  • Conditions
  • .edu
  • Patient
  • Meds
  • Tech
  • Social
  • Video
    • All
    • Physician
    • Practice
    • Policy
    • Finance
    • Conditions
    • .edu
    • Patient
    • Meds
    • Tech
    • Social
    • Video
    • About
    • Contact
    • Contribute
    • Book
    • Careers
    • Podcast
    • Recommended
    • Speaking

Is arthroscopic surgery for a partial meniscal tear unnecessary?

Jennifer Gunter, MD
Conditions
January 2, 2014
Share
Tweet
Share

Arthroscopic knee surgery is big business in the United States. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomies alone cost $4 billion per year. Yes, billion. But do they work?

I’ve written previously about arthroscopic surgery for a torn meniscus and how it adds nothing above and beyond physical therapy for people with arthritis. We also know that arthroscopic knee surgery for arthritis isn’t effective either. Given the poor performance of these other arthroscopic surgeries, answering the question of whether partial meniscectomies are effective is crucial.

Interestingly, as the authors of a new study looking at partial meniscectomy for meniscal tears point out, arthroscopic knee surgeries for arthritis have decreased since the studies showing their lack of efficacy were published, however, there has been a 50% increase in surgeries for meniscal tears. I suppose that could be attributed to the overuse of MRIs for knee pain (when did the clinical exam become obsolete?) and the fact that meniscal tears are very common (35% of people over the age of 50 will have a meniscus tear on MRI). However, the cynic in me wonders how many times another “diagnosis” was identified so some kind of surgery could be offered, either because the surgeon couldn’t think of something else to offer, the surgeon wanted to fill their time on that day, or the patient pressed so much for and operation that the surgeon gave in.

But I digress.

This new study is a wonderful prospective randomized double-blinded trial with an elegant sham procedure with the data fully evaluated and analyzed before the investigators were unblinded. Also, the surgeons did not participate in the post operative care so there was no way patients could be accidentally informed about their procedure, true meniscal surgery or simply a diagnostic arthroscopy.

The results? Arthroscopic surgery offers nothing for patients with a partial meniscal tear who do not have  arthritis.

Why does this matter? Well, there’s the $4 billion we are spending on direct medical costs for this unnecessary surgery. Surely that money could be used elsewhere? There are also the indirect costs of missed work and disability payments, raised health care premiums to pay for the unnecessary surgery, and of course the risk of surgical complications. (Don’t even get me started on how much we could save by preventing unnecessary hysterectomies).

As a pain medicine physician I appreciate the desire to get better as quickly as possible, but for most painful conditions the path to wellness doesn’t involve a scalpel and a surgery that will not produce the desired outcome is a worse option than no surgery. To invest the time, effort, risk, and great expense of surgery there must be proof that it offers a chance to help. Given the solid lack of evidence for partial meniscectomy Medicaid, Medicare, and insurance companies should stop reimbursing for it.

We accept so little of surgery from an efficacy and safety standpoint compared with medications. At least you can stop a medication, but you can’t undo a surgery. What if every procedure were required to have the same type of efficacy and safety data for approval as the FDA requires of medications?

Unnecessary surgeries are a huge driver of both health care costs and false expectations and if we don’t do something about it we will never be able to provide universal cost effective care. It’s simply a burden that we can’t afford in so many ways.

Jennifer Gunter is an obstetrician-gynecologist and author of The Preemie Primer. She blogs at her self-titled site, Dr. Jen Gunter.

Prev

Our spiritual state can influence how physical ailments feel

January 1, 2014 Kevin 3
…
Next

Why it's hard to keep your New Year's resolution

January 2, 2014 Kevin 0
…

Tagged as: Orthopedics, Surgery

Post navigation

< Previous Post
Our spiritual state can influence how physical ailments feel
Next Post >
Why it's hard to keep your New Year's resolution

ADVERTISEMENT

More by Jennifer Gunter, MD

  • The Ellen Show broadcasts potentially harmful information about ovarian cancer screening

    Jennifer Gunter, MD
  • Dear science: an appreciation

    Jennifer Gunter, MD
  • Are there too many female OB/GYNs?

    Jennifer Gunter, MD

More in Conditions

  • Addressing menstrual health inequities in adolescents

    Callia Georgoulis
  • Healing beyond the surface: Why proper chronic wound care matters

    Alvin May, MD
  • Why specialist pain clinics and addiction treatment services require strong primary care

    Olumuyiwa Bamgbade, MD
  • What a childhood stroke taught me about the future of neurosurgery and the promise of vagus nerve stimulation

    William J. Bannon IV
  • Facing terminal cancer as a doctor and mother

    Kelly Curtin-Hallinan, DO
  • Why doctors must stop ignoring unintentional weight loss in patients with obesity

    Samantha Malley, FNP-C
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • Forced voicemail and diagnosis codes are endangering patient access to medications

      Arthur Lazarus, MD, MBA | Meds
    • The One Big Beautiful Bill and the fragile heart of rural health care

      Holland Haynie, MD | Policy
    • America’s ER crisis: Why the system is collapsing from within

      Kristen Cline, BSN, RN | Conditions
    • Why timing, not surgery, determines patient survival

      Michael Karch, MD | Conditions
    • How early meetings and after-hours events penalize physician-mothers

      Samira Jeimy, MD, PhD and Menaka Pai, MD | Physician
    • FDA delays could end vital treatment for rare disease patients

      GJ van Londen, MD | Meds
  • Past 6 Months

    • Forced voicemail and diagnosis codes are endangering patient access to medications

      Arthur Lazarus, MD, MBA | Meds
    • How President Biden’s cognitive health shapes political and legal trust

      Muhamad Aly Rifai, MD | Conditions
    • Why are medical students turning away from primary care? [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • The One Big Beautiful Bill and the fragile heart of rural health care

      Holland Haynie, MD | Policy
    • Why “do no harm” might be harming modern medicine

      Sabooh S. Mubbashar, MD | Physician
    • Here’s what providers really need in a modern EHR

      Laura Kohlhagen, MD, MBA | Tech
  • Recent Posts

    • Addressing menstrual health inequities in adolescents

      Callia Georgoulis | Conditions
    • How to advance workforce development through research mentorship and evidence-based management

      Olumuyiwa Bamgbade, MD | Physician
    • The truth about perfection and identity in health care

      Ryan Nadelson, MD | Physician
    • Civil discourse as a leadership competency: the case for curiosity in medicine

      All Levels Leadership | Physician
    • Healing beyond the surface: Why proper chronic wound care matters

      Alvin May, MD | Conditions
    • Why specialist pain clinics and addiction treatment services require strong primary care

      Olumuyiwa Bamgbade, MD | Conditions

Subscribe to KevinMD and never miss a story!

Get free updates delivered free to your inbox.


Find jobs at
Careers by KevinMD.com

Search thousands of physician, PA, NP, and CRNA jobs now.

Learn more

View 9 Comments >

Founded in 2004 by Kevin Pho, MD, KevinMD.com is the web’s leading platform where physicians, advanced practitioners, nurses, medical students, and patients share their insight and tell their stories.

Social

  • Like on Facebook
  • Follow on Twitter
  • Connect on Linkedin
  • Subscribe on Youtube
  • Instagram

ADVERTISEMENT

  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • Forced voicemail and diagnosis codes are endangering patient access to medications

      Arthur Lazarus, MD, MBA | Meds
    • The One Big Beautiful Bill and the fragile heart of rural health care

      Holland Haynie, MD | Policy
    • America’s ER crisis: Why the system is collapsing from within

      Kristen Cline, BSN, RN | Conditions
    • Why timing, not surgery, determines patient survival

      Michael Karch, MD | Conditions
    • How early meetings and after-hours events penalize physician-mothers

      Samira Jeimy, MD, PhD and Menaka Pai, MD | Physician
    • FDA delays could end vital treatment for rare disease patients

      GJ van Londen, MD | Meds
  • Past 6 Months

    • Forced voicemail and diagnosis codes are endangering patient access to medications

      Arthur Lazarus, MD, MBA | Meds
    • How President Biden’s cognitive health shapes political and legal trust

      Muhamad Aly Rifai, MD | Conditions
    • Why are medical students turning away from primary care? [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • The One Big Beautiful Bill and the fragile heart of rural health care

      Holland Haynie, MD | Policy
    • Why “do no harm” might be harming modern medicine

      Sabooh S. Mubbashar, MD | Physician
    • Here’s what providers really need in a modern EHR

      Laura Kohlhagen, MD, MBA | Tech
  • Recent Posts

    • Addressing menstrual health inequities in adolescents

      Callia Georgoulis | Conditions
    • How to advance workforce development through research mentorship and evidence-based management

      Olumuyiwa Bamgbade, MD | Physician
    • The truth about perfection and identity in health care

      Ryan Nadelson, MD | Physician
    • Civil discourse as a leadership competency: the case for curiosity in medicine

      All Levels Leadership | Physician
    • Healing beyond the surface: Why proper chronic wound care matters

      Alvin May, MD | Conditions
    • Why specialist pain clinics and addiction treatment services require strong primary care

      Olumuyiwa Bamgbade, MD | Conditions

MedPage Today Professional

An Everyday Health Property Medpage Today
  • Terms of Use | Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
All Content © KevinMD, LLC
Site by Outthink Group

Is arthroscopic surgery for a partial meniscal tear unnecessary?
9 comments

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

Loading Comments...