While slogging through a crappy first draft of a document about the value of psychiatrists in mental health and substance use disorder services, I did a literature search for supporting evidence.
I found nothing. (1)
“So how exactly are we helpful?” I mused out loud. Maybe we aren’t: There are groups out there who do not believe that psychiatrists can or do help anyone.
I am an N of 1. …
Do psychiatrists have value? Yes, they do.
The first posting on my blog explained why I chose to name it “Auscultation.” I wrote that I wanted to promote a conversation, and that listening was essential to doing so. I went on to write: “With an obvious nod to my being a cardiologist, I believe auscultation has long been an act that defines us as physicians and connects us in a profound way with our patients. The act of …
Listening to the patient is the first part of the physical exam
Dear AMA and state medical boards,
The last few years have been a period of unprecedented change in the world of health care. The need to reign in costs, expand access, and ensure higher quality care — all at a time of rapid medical and technological advancements — has changed innumerable aspects of the practice of medicine.
Throughout this, one common theme has been the dedication and determination of hundreds of thousands …
Physicians are not providers: An open letter to the AMA and medical boards
Most people who apply to a graduate school and/or graduate medical programs apply to get accepted the first time of applying. No one wants to have to apply a second time and definitely not a third time. After a second rejection, a lot of people would probably recommended someone picking another field to enter or even giving up altogether. For me, both of my rejections were taken hard and still …
I got rejected from medical school twice. It was the best thing that happened to me.
Part of a series.
Urgent care clinics provide a useful service to the community, but their days may be numbered with survival questionable resulting from intense competition from the chain pharmacies and soon from Walmart.
Urgent care companies began to proliferate 30 years ago but have gained traction in recent years as emergency room wait times rapidly lengthened. Urgent care is less expensive than the ER, is open 24/7 or …
If urgent care centers don’t innovate, how long will they last?
A continuing series on physician online reputation. Created in partnership with the Doctors Company as part of their social media resources for physicians.
There are so many online platforms that doctors can get involved in today, and some may not know where to start. I want to share my approach.
The first step would be going on physician rating sites and making sure your information is accurate on …
How doctors can establish an online presence: A step by step approach
Recruitment season is my favorite time of year. The CVs pile into the database, and we sift through the resumes, searching for candidates that would make a great fit for our organization. Next, I get on the phone and assess their level of interest and try to sell them on everything we have to offer. We fly them out for a live interview, and the negotiations begin.
Last year was a …
Physicians looking for a new job should beware these 4 red flags
I spent a couple of hours today discussing a topic that has become increasingly important in the world in which we live, and which would have completely mystified an earlier generation of physicians. The subject was attribution. Simply put, how should one decide which patients “belong” to which doctors? On a more technical level, what algorithms should be employed to connect patients, or episodes of care for those patients, or …
Who’s in charge of the patient? It’s a question increasingly difficult to answer.
“How far did you go in school?”
This is a question that I ask every new patient as a matter of course.
Granted, I have gotten some very odd answers, including hearing from a very successful businessman who only finished the seventh grade, or a very psychotic person who has a double master’s degree. Not implausible, but certainly not expected or the mainstream answer from the majority of my patients.
Now, leaving the …
The question about education that this doctor asks every new patient
It’s no secret that I have a special place in my electronically-regulated heart for evidence. There’s a good reason for that. Our primary job as physicians is to avoid harming our patients, but it’s followed closely by our calling to help them in some way. The problem is that, until we test our theories, we don’t really know which treatments will help our patients (or which ones might harm them), …
A physician’s personal experience with evidence-based medicine
When a wife suddenly comes in for her husband’s appointment, I usually worry a little; when a husband shows up for his wife’s visit, I sometimes worry a lot.
I have come to expect that when I enter an exam room, and a male patient has his wife with him in the room, she is there to make sure I hear some part of his symptom history that he has never …
What worries me about husbands and wives in the exam room
Last week I was playing golf with some friends. The Boston area has been having a bit of an Indian summer, and we are lucky to still be getting out there (long may it last). The conversation during one of the holes turned to health care information technology, when my friend, who is also a physician, told me about his experiences with a (certain famous) new electronic medical record that’s just been installed in their …
The bait and switch of health care IT
Christine Sinsky, MD, from the American Medical Association interviews Pamela Wible, MD, after her TEDMED talk. Watch periscope video here. Fully transcribed below:
Dr. Sinsky: This afternoon we’re here in Palm Springs, and I’m delighted to be here with Dr. Pamela Wible, who gave a terrific TED talk last night. I’m Dr. Christine Sinsky, the vice president of professional satisfaction at the …
The iconoclastic psychiatrist Thomas Szasz said that mental illness was metaphorical, not real, because mental diseases lacked biological substrates. The absence of a substrate predisposes psychiatry to overdiagnosis and avoiding overdiagnosis is psychiatry’s biggest challenge. This challenge has been taken up by Allen Frances in Saving Normal. Like Szasz, Frances writes in cultured, erudite prose. Unlike Szasz, Frances believes that psychiatric illnesses are real. To save the mentally ill, to save …
DSM-5 is psychiatry’s maladaptation in the grey zone masquerading as science
“I quit residency.”
Three words that many physicians couldn’t ever imagine coming out of their mouth, but for me, I say it all the time, usually with a smile on my face. I was a year and a half into my family medicine residency and decided it was enough. My decision mostly revolved around the birth of my son. My husband (a resident in the same program) and I planned to …
This doctor quit residency. And now she’s truly happy.
Amid ongoing health care transformation, clinicians will increasingly face the tension that the late physician and health services researcher John M. Eisenberg, MD, MACP, described over 30 years ago: providing high-value care with simultaneous commitments to patients and society.
Physicians have always been charged as patient agents to advocate for patients’ best interests. Simultaneously, however, they are tasked with considering the societal good by using resources wisely. While these commitments often …
Value to patients and value to society: How can doctors balance the tension?
“I admire anyone who has the guts to write anything at all.”
– E. B. White
“All you have to do is write one true sentence. Write the truest sentence that you know.”
– Ernest Hemingway
“Writing is easy. All you have to do is cross out the wrong words.”
– Mark Twain
“There is no greater agony than bearing an untold story inside you.”
– Maya Angelou
“There is nothing to writing. All you do is sit down at …
A surgeon blogs for one year. Here’s what she learned.
The New York Post is reporting that women in New York are getting labiaplasties to look and feel better in tight athletic wear. They quote a patient, Veronica R., as wanting to “look like Barbie.”
According to the Post, on the Upper East Side in New York there are apparently “a large number” of women who want to look “sleeker in so-called athleisure wear, made from Lycra-like fabrics that often …
Don’t make yourself look like Barbie to fit into yoga pants. Please.
From ancient times, doctors have appreciated that, for all their similarities, no two patients are exactly alike. This understanding is what made physicians act like, and earn society’s respect as, professionals.
The commercialization of health care has brought in managers from other industries and other branches of academia, and their rise to power has been predicated on their ability to treat patients and doctors not as individuals, but as small cogs …
It’s time to stop comparing health care to manufacturing
Combine a hot start-up valued at 9 billion dollars, an articulate Stanford drop-out CEO with celebrity-like press coverage, and a recent Wall Street Journal report that calls into question the reliability of the company’s “revolutionary” testing, and you have the perfect storm to set the internet abuzz about Theranos.
Amidst the melee of accusations, “change-the-world” start-up jargon, and anecdotes of incongruent lab results, something has been missing: an organized, …
4 questions about Theranos that are actually worth discussing
Get free updates delivered free to your inbox.
