Skip to content
  • About
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Book
  • Careers
  • Podcast
  • Recommended
  • Speaking
  • All
  • Physician
  • Practice
  • Policy
  • Finance
  • Conditions
  • .edu
  • Patient
  • Meds
  • Tech
  • Social
  • Video
    • All
    • Physician
    • Practice
    • Policy
    • Finance
    • Conditions
    • .edu
    • Patient
    • Meds
    • Tech
    • Social
    • Video
    • About
    • Contact
    • Contribute
    • Book
    • Careers
    • Podcast
    • Recommended
    • Speaking

Defending the residency Match and its algorithm

Jeremy J. Robbins
Education
May 25, 2014
Share
Tweet
Share

KevinMD.com recently published the article “It’s time to make the Match disappear” written by medical student Amy Ho. I firmly agree with her that the current match system is wildly inefficient and needs fixing. However, she is throwing the baby out with the bath water in abandoning the algorithm which yields an extremely effective system.

Firstly, when one examines her data, which in itself is correct, one also needs to examine what comprises the data. Her argument that 25% of DOs and IMGs don’t match is neither representative nor fully accurate. Being a DO myself, I recognize that the match was created with the focus of training U.S. MDs. While inconvenient for me, it is simply the premise for which the NRMP was created. Whereas my unmatched DO colleagues retroactively seize unfilled spots in the DO match, the U.S. MDs have no backup plan. Yes, Caribbean trained MDs have an even tougher time but, unfortunately this has always been the case. While this route was possibly their only option to bring their dream of becoming a physician to fruition, the responsible ones understood the enormous risk of training outside US.  Thus, the 5% non-match rate of U.S. MDs is actually very impressive, and the only real relevant statistic.

Other parts of her data regarding salaries and dual degrees are also oversimplified. She is correct that some postdoctoral graduates make as much as $35,000 more but this is ignoring the truth that most JD and PhD graduates face an even fiercer job market and are quite often unemployed (or “underemployed”) many months after graduation. These postdoctorals often will never receive the enormous salary jump physicians earn upon leaving residency.

Furthermore , I will humbly admit that I am nowhere near ready to practice medicine without supervision. I can handle writing off the $35,000 to understanding that residency is still a learning process, at least for the humble. In regards to dual degree compensation, free markets do not compensate for being inappropriately overqualified. You get compensated for the relevant attributes you bring for the position. I have a difficult time seeing how a JD or MBA produces a more qualified intern. While a post-residency job may utilitize dual degrees, I surmise that most program directors regard it impressively, but ultimately as nothing more than a feather in the hat during residency. Too many times, we stay in academia so long we forget that initials do not necessarily make you a better employee. Not to mention that our efforts to correct these financial issue are far less valuable compared to impending larger issues we face, or more appropriately, from which we’re currently burying our heads in the sand. Medicaid’s SGR and lack of inflation based reimbursements both come to mind.

After all this, she makes several arguments about students’ dreams being shattered, whether it is due to location or matching to a different specialty. Our parents may have told us we could be anything we wanted to be but unfortunately that is not how even the free market works. Competitive spots go to those with the highest qualifications which is the same as in the real world. The most qualified candidates apply to very few places and are not forced to abandon their desired specialty. Having a free market does not automatically mean every applicant will interview for their dream spot as she implies. There are still the same spots and the same number of qualified applicants. Even with a degree from MIT one cannot work for Google simply because one desires. In real life, non-medical people still face immense obstacles and often sacrifice locations and job specialties with higher unemployment rates.

Finally, in the financial regards to her article, she claims free market tactics would lower interview costs and increase resident salaries. While there are ways to reduce costs, I will save them for a future article. The algorithm itself is practically free and thus, the problem lies elsewhere in the entire process. As she mentions, the interviews are where the costs are, but she is wrong to assume a free market simply cures this.

A free market will still require many interviews, especially if programs are allowed to delay their final decisions weeks to months after the interview. As mentioned, the best candidates will still have fewer programs to which they need to apply in order to have their choice of residency. Likewise, less competitive candidates will still need to go on many interviews and may have to sacrifice location or specialty. A free market does not mean you are free to do what you want, you are simply free to try and often fail. Even after having personally spent $10,000 on the interview trail, I cannot complain because I know my non-medical friends have spent similar amounts of money on their own career paths. If she is contending that over-applying and over-interviewing are the culprits of reducible costs then she is correct. However, there are far easier fixes for this problem without abandoning the algorithm.

While her complaints would still exist (or worsen) in a free market, if her underlying point was that both medical school and the match are wildly inefficient, then she is spot on. However, switching to a free market is the epitome of throwing the baby out with the bathtub. The system’s basic construct still yields the best realistic outcomes for all parties involved. The two years that I worked in the free market before medical school helped me learn how correct Mick Jagger was when he said, “You can’t always get what you want”.

Life is not about being happy with every situation. It is about rising above the unexpected detours and finding happiness in spite of them. I firmly agree there are ways to increase the NRMP’s efficiency for both involved parties. However, a free market is not one of them.

Jeremy J. Robbins is a medical student.

Prev

The VA wait list scandal: A sign of our future?

May 25, 2014 Kevin 8
…
Next

The depressed may appear like you and me

May 25, 2014 Kevin 23
…

Tagged as: Residency

Post navigation

< Previous Post
The VA wait list scandal: A sign of our future?
Next Post >
The depressed may appear like you and me

ADVERTISEMENT

More in Education

  • Dear July intern: It’s normal to feel clueless—here’s what matters

    Tomi Mitchell, MD
  • Why medical schools must ditch lectures and embrace active learning

    Arlen Meyers, MD, MBA
  • Why helping people means more than getting an MD

    Vaishali Jha
  • Residency match tips: Building mentorship, research, and community

    Simran Kaur, MD and Eva Shelton, MD
  • How I learned to stop worrying and love AI

    Rajeev Dutta
  • Why medical student debt is killing primary care in America

    Alexander Camp
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • Forced voicemail and diagnosis codes are endangering patient access to medications

      Arthur Lazarus, MD, MBA | Meds
    • The One Big Beautiful Bill and the fragile heart of rural health care

      Holland Haynie, MD | Policy
    • America’s ER crisis: Why the system is collapsing from within

      Kristen Cline, BSN, RN | Conditions
    • Why timing, not surgery, determines patient survival

      Michael Karch, MD | Conditions
    • How early meetings and after-hours events penalize physician-mothers

      Samira Jeimy, MD, PhD and Menaka Pai, MD | Physician
    • FDA delays could end vital treatment for rare disease patients

      GJ van Londen, MD | Meds
  • Past 6 Months

    • Forced voicemail and diagnosis codes are endangering patient access to medications

      Arthur Lazarus, MD, MBA | Meds
    • How President Biden’s cognitive health shapes political and legal trust

      Muhamad Aly Rifai, MD | Conditions
    • Why are medical students turning away from primary care? [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • The One Big Beautiful Bill and the fragile heart of rural health care

      Holland Haynie, MD | Policy
    • Why “do no harm” might be harming modern medicine

      Sabooh S. Mubbashar, MD | Physician
    • Here’s what providers really need in a modern EHR

      Laura Kohlhagen, MD, MBA | Tech
  • Recent Posts

    • Addressing menstrual health inequities in adolescents

      Callia Georgoulis | Conditions
    • How to advance workforce development through research mentorship and evidence-based management

      Olumuyiwa Bamgbade, MD | Physician
    • The truth about perfection and identity in health care

      Ryan Nadelson, MD | Physician
    • Civil discourse as a leadership competency: the case for curiosity in medicine

      All Levels Leadership | Physician
    • Healing beyond the surface: Why proper chronic wound care matters

      Alvin May, MD | Conditions
    • Why specialist pain clinics and addiction treatment services require strong primary care

      Olumuyiwa Bamgbade, MD | Conditions

Subscribe to KevinMD and never miss a story!

Get free updates delivered free to your inbox.


Find jobs at
Careers by KevinMD.com

Search thousands of physician, PA, NP, and CRNA jobs now.

Learn more

Leave a Comment

Founded in 2004 by Kevin Pho, MD, KevinMD.com is the web’s leading platform where physicians, advanced practitioners, nurses, medical students, and patients share their insight and tell their stories.

Social

  • Like on Facebook
  • Follow on Twitter
  • Connect on Linkedin
  • Subscribe on Youtube
  • Instagram

ADVERTISEMENT

  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • Forced voicemail and diagnosis codes are endangering patient access to medications

      Arthur Lazarus, MD, MBA | Meds
    • The One Big Beautiful Bill and the fragile heart of rural health care

      Holland Haynie, MD | Policy
    • America’s ER crisis: Why the system is collapsing from within

      Kristen Cline, BSN, RN | Conditions
    • Why timing, not surgery, determines patient survival

      Michael Karch, MD | Conditions
    • How early meetings and after-hours events penalize physician-mothers

      Samira Jeimy, MD, PhD and Menaka Pai, MD | Physician
    • FDA delays could end vital treatment for rare disease patients

      GJ van Londen, MD | Meds
  • Past 6 Months

    • Forced voicemail and diagnosis codes are endangering patient access to medications

      Arthur Lazarus, MD, MBA | Meds
    • How President Biden’s cognitive health shapes political and legal trust

      Muhamad Aly Rifai, MD | Conditions
    • Why are medical students turning away from primary care? [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • The One Big Beautiful Bill and the fragile heart of rural health care

      Holland Haynie, MD | Policy
    • Why “do no harm” might be harming modern medicine

      Sabooh S. Mubbashar, MD | Physician
    • Here’s what providers really need in a modern EHR

      Laura Kohlhagen, MD, MBA | Tech
  • Recent Posts

    • Addressing menstrual health inequities in adolescents

      Callia Georgoulis | Conditions
    • How to advance workforce development through research mentorship and evidence-based management

      Olumuyiwa Bamgbade, MD | Physician
    • The truth about perfection and identity in health care

      Ryan Nadelson, MD | Physician
    • Civil discourse as a leadership competency: the case for curiosity in medicine

      All Levels Leadership | Physician
    • Healing beyond the surface: Why proper chronic wound care matters

      Alvin May, MD | Conditions
    • Why specialist pain clinics and addiction treatment services require strong primary care

      Olumuyiwa Bamgbade, MD | Conditions

MedPage Today Professional

An Everyday Health Property Medpage Today
  • Terms of Use | Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
All Content © KevinMD, LLC
Site by Outthink Group

Leave a Comment

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

Loading Comments...