Skip to content
  • About
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Book
  • Careers
  • Podcast
  • Recommended
  • Speaking
  • All
  • Physician
  • Practice
  • Policy
  • Finance
  • Conditions
  • .edu
  • Patient
  • Meds
  • Tech
  • Social
  • Video
    • All
    • Physician
    • Practice
    • Policy
    • Finance
    • Conditions
    • .edu
    • Patient
    • Meds
    • Tech
    • Social
    • Video
    • About
    • Contact
    • Contribute
    • Book
    • Careers
    • Podcast
    • Recommended
    • Speaking

The history of antivaccination sentiment

Caroline Castleman
Conditions
August 8, 2019
Share
Tweet
Share

In 1902, a smallpox outbreak infected thousands of people across the northeastern United States. That year, in Massachusetts alone, 2,314 people were infected, and 284 died. This was not unusual for early-twentieth-century Massachusetts: The smallpox vaccine had been invented more than a century earlier and had markedly reduced the incidence of the disease, but the diminished threat of illness motivated fewer people to opt for vaccination. City officials in Cambridge, noting the growing vulnerability of its citizens, made smallpox vaccines a requirement. Children with proof of medical unfitness for vaccination were the only people exempted; any adult objectors would be fined $5.

Henning Jacobson refused to comply. He was fined, but not forced to be vaccinated; the law did not provide for any intervention in response to noncompliance. Jacobson was not satisfied with avoiding the vaccine, and he protested the fine; he and his son had both reacted badly to earlier vaccines and Jacobson believed he had the right to make his own health care decisions. His case ended up in the Supreme Court, which ruled in favor of the state in Jacobson v. Massachusetts. In the interest of protecting the public health, the court found, states can enact “reasonable regulations” to protect the safety of their inhabitants, whose rights to be “freed from restraint” are not absolute.

Vaccine objections and religion

Jacobson is especially resonant this summer; New York responded to the current measles outbreak by eliminating religious exemptions for vaccinations in June. For more than a century, courts have upheld states’ authority to require vaccines even for religious or philosophical objectors, and it was largely due to expansive vaccination efforts that measles was declared eradicated in the United States in 2000. But 45 states and Washington, D.C., offer religious exemptions. Fifteen states also honor refusals on personal or moral grounds.

States are not obligated to offer religious exemptions. They withdraw them only in response to a serious public health crisis. Perhaps this type of objection is permitted because arguing against religious doctrine is difficult, if not impossible. And given this country’s powerful commitment to personal liberty, it makes sense that many states have opted to recognize the role religion plays in personal health care decisions.

Philosophical concerns and public health

There is less nationwide agreement, however, on the issue raised by Jacobson. Is a personal, nonreligious belief about vaccines grounds for refusal? The 1905 decision—still cited to support restrictions on personal liberty in the interest of promoting public health—is certainly in favor of vaccination, even against philosophical objections. Many in the health care community have the same view. Dr. Stephen G. Baum wrote for The Doctor’s Tablet in May that promoting herd immunity above individual beliefs is “a concept that must continue to hold sway.” And the American Academy of Pediatrics ranked the elimination of all nonmedical exemptions to vaccinating children this year’s top priority, above even safeguarding children’s health amid family separations at the border.

Still, philosophical objections can exempt people from vaccinating their children in 15 states, and combating the concerns that motivate those refusals will be critical for the provision of good care and for the maintenance of herd immunity. This is a complex task in part because personal objections to vaccination are so varied. Vaccine hesitancy can stem from distrust of health care practitioners, of pharmaceutical companies, or of the government—an especially relevant concern, as only 17 percent of Americans reported trust in the federal government this year.

To address all root causes of objection would require a shift in public attitudes toward science, medicine, and public health interventions—a worthy task, but unachievable in the short term. However, there are opportunities for progress. A Washington State law requiring people to speak with doctors before getting a vaccine exemption was associated with a 40 percent reduction in exemptions granted. And sensitivity to the vulnerability of certain populations to misinformation might be critical in preventing events such as the 2011 measles outbreak affecting the Minnesota Somali population, allegedly caused by a series of interventions by Andrew Wakefield, a former British doctor whose debunked research claimed a causal relationship between the measles/mumps/rubella vaccine and autism.

Antivaccination sentiment is not new, nor is it independent of political and social context; there is much we can learn from the conditions behind Jacobson and from the evolution of the vaccination debate since. Health care professionals and patients alike can gain insight from the medical and social history of vaccination as we try to maximize both public health and respect for personal beliefs.

Caroline Castleman bioethics intern who blogs at the Doctor’s Tablet.

Image credit: Shutterstock.com

Prev

A physician's advice on extra cash flow

August 8, 2019 Kevin 0
…
Next

A doctor survived a day without a computer. Here's how he did it.

August 9, 2019 Kevin 0
…

ADVERTISEMENT

Tagged as: Public Health & Policy

Post navigation

< Previous Post
A physician's advice on extra cash flow
Next Post >
A doctor survived a day without a computer. Here's how he did it.

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

  • A history of health care reform

    Behrouz Zand, MD
  • Every patient has a rich history behind their current state of health

    Ton La, Jr., MD, JD
  • Major medical groups back mandatory COVID vaccine for health care workers

    Molly Walker
  • Are negative news cycles and social media injurious to our health?

    Rabia Jalal, MD
  • What does Kelly Loeffler’s health plan do to coverage for preexisting conditions?

    Robert Laszewski
  • HIV/AIDS vaccine underscores need for better health access

    Alyson O’Daniel, PhD

More in Conditions

  • The myth of biohacking your way past death

    Larry Kaskel, MD
  • Why Hollywood’s allergy jokes are dangerous

    Lianne Mandelbaum, PT
  • Coconut oil’s role in Alzheimer’s and depression

    Marc Arginteanu, MD
  • Ancient health secrets for modern life

    Larry Kaskel, MD
  • How the internet broke the doctor-parent trust

    Wendy L. Hunter, MD
  • Mpox isn’t over: A silent epidemic is growing

    Melvin Sanicas, MD
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • The human case for preserving the nipple after mastectomy

      Thomas Amburn, MD | Conditions
    • Nuclear verdicts and rising costs: How inflation is reshaping medical malpractice claims

      Robert E. White, Jr. & The Doctors Company | Policy
    • How new loan caps could destroy diversity in medical education

      Caleb Andrus-Gazyeva | Policy
    • IMGs are the future of U.S. primary care

      Adam Brandon Bondoc, MD | Physician
    • The myth of biohacking your way past death

      Larry Kaskel, MD | Conditions
    • Why doctors struggle with family caregiving and how to find grace [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
  • Past 6 Months

    • Health equity in Inland Southern California requires urgent action

      Vishruth Nagam | Policy
    • How restrictive opioid policies worsen the crisis

      Kayvan Haddadan, MD | Physician
    • Why primary care needs better dermatology training

      Alex Siauw | Conditions
    • Why pain doctors face unfair scrutiny and harsh penalties in California

      Kayvan Haddadan, MD | Physician
    • How a doctor defied a hurricane to save a life

      Dharam Persaud-Sharma, MD, PhD | Physician
    • What street medicine taught me about healing

      Alina Kang | Education
  • Recent Posts

    • The myth of biohacking your way past death

      Larry Kaskel, MD | Conditions
    • How trust and communication power successful dyad leadership in health care [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Why Hollywood’s allergy jokes are dangerous

      Lianne Mandelbaum, PT | Conditions
    • How I learned to love my unique name as a doctor

      Zoran Naumovski, MD | Physician
    • My first week on night float as a medical student

      Amish Jain | Education
    • What Beauty and the Beast taught me about risk

      Jayson Greenberg, MD | Physician

Subscribe to KevinMD and never miss a story!

Get free updates delivered free to your inbox.


Find jobs at
Careers by KevinMD.com

Search thousands of physician, PA, NP, and CRNA jobs now.

Learn more

Leave a Comment

Founded in 2004 by Kevin Pho, MD, KevinMD.com is the web’s leading platform where physicians, advanced practitioners, nurses, medical students, and patients share their insight and tell their stories.

Social

  • Like on Facebook
  • Follow on Twitter
  • Connect on Linkedin
  • Subscribe on Youtube
  • Instagram

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • The human case for preserving the nipple after mastectomy

      Thomas Amburn, MD | Conditions
    • Nuclear verdicts and rising costs: How inflation is reshaping medical malpractice claims

      Robert E. White, Jr. & The Doctors Company | Policy
    • How new loan caps could destroy diversity in medical education

      Caleb Andrus-Gazyeva | Policy
    • IMGs are the future of U.S. primary care

      Adam Brandon Bondoc, MD | Physician
    • The myth of biohacking your way past death

      Larry Kaskel, MD | Conditions
    • Why doctors struggle with family caregiving and how to find grace [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
  • Past 6 Months

    • Health equity in Inland Southern California requires urgent action

      Vishruth Nagam | Policy
    • How restrictive opioid policies worsen the crisis

      Kayvan Haddadan, MD | Physician
    • Why primary care needs better dermatology training

      Alex Siauw | Conditions
    • Why pain doctors face unfair scrutiny and harsh penalties in California

      Kayvan Haddadan, MD | Physician
    • How a doctor defied a hurricane to save a life

      Dharam Persaud-Sharma, MD, PhD | Physician
    • What street medicine taught me about healing

      Alina Kang | Education
  • Recent Posts

    • The myth of biohacking your way past death

      Larry Kaskel, MD | Conditions
    • How trust and communication power successful dyad leadership in health care [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Why Hollywood’s allergy jokes are dangerous

      Lianne Mandelbaum, PT | Conditions
    • How I learned to love my unique name as a doctor

      Zoran Naumovski, MD | Physician
    • My first week on night float as a medical student

      Amish Jain | Education
    • What Beauty and the Beast taught me about risk

      Jayson Greenberg, MD | Physician

MedPage Today Professional

An Everyday Health Property Medpage Today
  • Terms of Use | Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
All Content © KevinMD, LLC
Site by Outthink Group

Leave a Comment

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

Loading Comments...