Listen and followApple PodcastsSpotifyYouTubeMore apps · Browse all episodes
A physical therapist spent one night in the hospital, then got a $9,000 bill because his insurer said it wasn’t necessary. Mitchell Batavia is a physical therapist and an associate professor who teaches evidence-based practice. This episode is based on his article “Not medically necessary: the three words that cost me $9,000,” published on KevinMD. You will hear how a prostate biopsy led to urinary retention, an ambulance ride, and an overnight stay he now believes he probably did not need, and how the hospital forgave the bill a year later. He explains why clinicians should discuss costs and alternatives alongside the guidelines, why patient preference belongs in the decision, and why randomized trials describe averages rather than individuals. He also shares the question every patient should ask before agreeing to stay overnight. Press play to hear why the message on his hat is “Think for yourself.”
If this episode helped, follow The Podcast by KevinMD on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, and leave a rating.
Partner with me on the KevinMD platform. With more than 100 million impressions a year and nearly 750,000 followers, subscribers and email recipients across my channels, I give you direct access to the doctors and patients who matter most. Whether you need a sponsored article, email campaign, video interview, or a spot right here on the podcast, I offer the trusted space your brand deserves to be heard. Let’s work together to tell your story.
PARTNER WITH KEVINMD → https://kevinmd.com/influencer
SUBSCRIBE TO THE PODCAST → https://www.kevinmd.com/podcast
Transcript
Kevin Pho: Hi, and welcome to the show. Subscribe at KevinMD.com/podcast. Today, we welcome Mitchell Batavia. He’s a physical therapist. Today’s KevinMD article is “Not medically necessary: the three words that cost me $9,000.” Mitchell, welcome to the show.
Mitchell Batavia: Thank you very much. Nice to be here, Kevin.
Kevin Pho: All right, let’s start by briefly sharing your story, and then tell us why you decided to share this illustration and article on KevinMD.
Mitchell Batavia: Yes. The story goes that I’ve been followed for my prostate for several years now because of a high PSA, and I’ve periodically gotten images for it and also biopsies. So I went in for my third biopsy. This one was a little bit different, I think a bit more aggressive, and in the past, there was never a problem. This one ended up with me going to the emergency room.
I think it was the following night that I started voiding less and less. At some point, I stopped being able to void at all, which was a very new experience for me, because that had never happened in my entire life. How many times do you try to void and then you can’t? It’s an alarming situation. I was told to always drink lots of fluids so as to avoid a blood clot, but apparently a blood clot must have formed. I contacted an overnight physician on call, who said that I had to get catheterized immediately. I had to go over to the ER.
So I called 911. I wasn’t sure whether I should drive or not, so I mistakenly called 911. They sent me an ambulance, but instead of going through all the red lights, they stopped everywhere. I said, “What are you doing?” My systolic pressure was up to about 190 at that point. They apparently didn’t take it very seriously. Of course, I wasn’t in cardiac arrest or anything. I finally went to a closer hospital, because I couldn’t bear the pain anymore. It was this gripping feeling around my loins, as if my kidneys were shutting down.
So I went to the ER, and they put me into a room, and then nothing happened. Thankfully, my wife was able to talk to the nurses and eventually get one of them in to pop the cork, right? So much fluid came out, like three bags. The residents kept coming in and peeking. They were sort of entertained or amazed by it.
Let me preface this by saying that everyone was really excellent in terms of their medical behavior. So I have nothing against any of my experiences in the ER. At one point, they said, “You put out a lot of fluid. Your electrolytes are out of balance. We’d like to keep you overnight.” It was Saturday morning, 2 in the morning. I was really worried about my kidneys, because they said there was possible kidney damage and they had to do some blood work, since the fluid rushes through the kidneys so quickly after that. I was willing to leave, but look, the docs said I should stay. Who am I to question that? So it never occurred to me to ask whether this was going to be covered by insurance. And apparently the insurance company didn’t feel it was medically necessary; I got the denial a week or two later.
I stayed overnight, and the food wasn’t as bad as I expected. Everyone was very pleasant. They took care of me. They did an excellent job. The issue is that I probably didn’t belong there. I probably could have gotten some blood work as an outpatient the next day, and I would have been fine walking around with a Foley catheter strapped to my leg for a couple of days. But I just acquiesced. I wanted to be the good patient, right? Because I’m a therapist myself.
I’m also, by the way, an associate professor, and I teach evidence-based practice and highlight the importance of its third pillar, which is what? Patient preference: talking to the patient. I wish that had happened when I got my biopsy, to weigh the risks and the benefits. How important is this? Or are you just following some blind protocol? That’s my issue. I think I know more about evidence-based practice than a lot of these physicians do, and so I’m very active about it.
That’s when I did the cartoon. I sent it to you, and you said, “Well, how about a story with that?” I was really so jaded from last summer, when this happened, that I didn’t want to revisit it. But I thought to myself, “I really like publishing. I do it all the time. Let me see if I can pull something together.” I was able to write something in about thirty minutes, and I eventually sent it to you maybe a month later, because I wanted the cartoon to be shown. I thought, “I wish he could show it.” And so that’s it.
It cost me somewhere between $8,000 and $9,000. If you round it out, it’s probably around $9,000. The ambulance was about $800. That’s an expensive limousine. I had to pay about $200 of that. It was just shocking. I spent so much time on the phone with the insurance company, with the hospital, and with the billing department. It was possibly a coding issue. I said, “Make sure you put in the right codes.” And they said, “Don’t worry about it.”
Only recently, a year later, when I checked my account for that particular hospital, I found out that they had forgiven it. They had initially said, “Don’t worry about it.” I guess they hoped they would get paid by somebody, and maybe they look to people who are insured to make up for people who don’t have insurance. I don’t know how it works. It’s very complicated, to me anyway. But the good news is that I didn’t actually have to write out a check. It took a year to find that out, though, with that hanging over my head. And I felt so stupid for not thinking about medical necessity. I teach it. I understand it. And maybe I shouldn’t have been in the hospital.
The issue here, talking to clinicians, and I know that’s one of your prompts, is to tell clinicians, “Look, you really need to not just make a recommendation, but consider costs. Consider the cost to the patient as well,” because that’s part of patient preference too. And think of alternatives. For instance, if they had presented me with the option, “We’d really like you to stay overnight, but if you really object, we’ll strap a Foley to you and you can come by in the morning. It won’t be as good, but it’ll probably suffice.” In other words, give alternatives. Have a conversation with patients. Have a real conversation. Don’t just think about the third column of evidence-based practice. Actually have a conversation, give alternatives, and think about health care costs, which are what? Out of control. When you’re talking about $9,000 for an overnight stay, which is probably equivalent to going on a safari in Africa for three weeks, it’s crazy. OK, I’ve spoken long enough.
Real physician voices, twice a week
Free, and one click to unsubscribe.
Kevin Pho: So let me ask about who did the denial, just so I get the story straight. You went to the emergency department that night. It was 2 a.m., and you were obviously in pain. The hospital asked you to stay over, and then, however much time later, you got a denial. So this sounds like it was retrospective. The insurance company probably reviewed your chart and felt that the stay wasn’t medically necessary, and that’s why you were billed. Is that fair to say?
Mitchell Batavia: Yes. They said, “You’re responsible for the bill.” And I can’t completely fault them. I don’t know. If my potassium is really high, will I get a heart attack if I say no?
Kevin Pho: But is it fair to the hospital and the clinicians? Because we are, of course, looking at this retrospectively, and I’m so happy to hear that everything went OK from a medical standpoint and that you’re doing OK. But at that moment, the health care team didn’t have all that information. They didn’t quite know which path this was going to take, right? So at that moment, it’s hard for those physicians to know what we know now in retrospect, that what you had was probably relatively benign. So how do you square those two: something looked back upon when you already know the outcome, versus something at 2 a.m. where they have to make a decision?
Mitchell Batavia: Right. Well, I think it’s really hard for a patient to think straight when they’re going through something like that. And my situation is far easier than what a lot of people go through. My brother broke his neck. He became a patient with a spinal cord injury. That’s a hell of a lot more serious. But in both cases, you’re in your own little world, and you don’t think about cost at all.
You just need to be transparent with patients and say, “Look, we really don’t know.” It is difficult. Clinical decision-making is gray. It’s blurry. We don’t know everything for certain. That’s why they use probability. That’s why they use confidence intervals, right? Because we don’t know for sure about the outcome and how accurate our predictions are going to be. So say, “Look, I’m not God. I really can’t predict. We usually do it this way. The clinical guidelines say that we should do this, and of course, I don’t want to go against what the clinical guidelines say.” But patient preference does have a role in modifying that. Why? Because randomized controlled trials, and I don’t have to tell you this, Kevin, are about averages. They’re not about individuals. So the role of the physician, the clinician, and the therapist is to take those group averages and customize them to the patient’s situation.
Physicians know that. But I think there’s such power in group decisions and clinical guidelines. That’s probably why I kept going for these prostate biopsies: Maybe the clinical guidelines at that particular hospital say that every so many years you need to get a biopsy if your PSA is over a certain amount. Well, just have a conversation with the patient and say, “Look, this is what the guidelines say, but I understand that there could be some risks, and this is what could happen: You may end up in an emergency room being catheterized.” Just have a real conversation. And that will absolve the clinician, I think, who can say, “Look, I told them everything I know about it. I didn’t withhold anything.”
But if you just say, “We think you should stay over,” and you don’t give other options, and the person is worried about renal failure, you have to help the patient out more. Is this covered by insurance or not? “We don’t really know, so you might actually get an $8,000 or $9,000 bill next month.” That would have helped me. I would have said, “Well, I feel pretty good now, thanks a lot. Just strap this thing to my leg, and I’ll go. I’ll come back in the morning.”
And that’s the other thing: Make sure that your family is with you in these ERs. My wife was with me. If she hadn’t been with me, I would still be on a gurney waiting for somebody to come and catheterize me, and every second was really, really painful for me. It was this gripping, tightening, pressing compression when you just can’t void. It’s a weird situation. I don’t know if you’ve ever experienced it. It’s really scary.
Kevin Pho: Now, for the patients who are listening to you, if they are unfortunately in that situation at 2 in the morning and have to go to the emergency department, what’s the one question you want every patient to ask before agreeing to stay overnight?
Mitchell Batavia: Is it really necessary? Can I go home? Look, you could get infections just by staying in hospitals. You could be healthy and come out with an infection, right? So what are the different options?
The other thing I would like to say is about agreeing to these screenings and biopsies before this whole thing happened. When you want to be a good patient, you want to agree. You don’t want to say no. And by the way, who wants to get cancer? So the doctors certainly look out for the patient, but they also are probably held to clinical guidelines or whatever their hospital is telling them they need to do. I don’t really know the backstory to that. But for me, and I’m not telling anybody else this, I’m going to start saying no. I’m going to start saying no, and continue to ask, “What is the clinical rationale for doing this biopsy?” For example, I would be getting ultrasounds in my prostate situation. What additional information will this uncomfortable ultrasound give me? I would never get an answer to that, and eventually I did. You know what the answer was? “It’s always good to have more information.” But that’s not satisfying. That’s not helpful. That doesn’t help with a clinical decision.
And the thing that shocked me the most, after a discussion, and I’m not going to mention any hospitals or anything, was what one individual said to me. I asked, “Why am I getting all of these invasive procedures constantly without an understanding of what they do in terms of clinical decision-making?” And the answer was, “Yeah, I wish patients would say no more.” That was shocking to me. In other words, they rely on the patient to make their own decision without all the information in front of them. They’re saying, “Look, we want you to take this test, this test, and this screening test,” and these are all invasive. And in the back of their mind, they’re saying, “Gee, I hope he doesn’t say yes to all of them.” I mean, what is that? What is that?
Kevin Pho: We’re talking to Mitchell Batavia, physical therapist. Today’s KevinMD article is “Not medically necessary: the three words that cost me $9,000.” Mitchell, we’ll end with your take-home message to the KevinMD audience.
Mitchell Batavia: The take-home message is on my hat here. It says, “Think for yourself.” Think for yourself, and try to get as much information as you can about your own care. And if you’re not satisfied, go somewhere else.
Kevin Pho: Mitchell, thank you for sharing your story, time, and insight, and thanks again for coming on the show.
Mitchell Batavia: Thank you.
Listen and followApple PodcastsSpotifyYouTubeMore apps · Browse all episodes

