Every fall, Medicare beneficiaries receive a copy of Medicare & You, the federal government’s official Medicare handbook. My copy covering New York City and surrounding counties arrived recently, and I find it confusing. It contains 131 pages explaining the options available to people who have already qualified for Medicare and covers Original Medicare, Parts A and B, Medicare Advantage Plans, with 71 choices, Medicare Supplement Insurance (Medigap) with 12 plan designs each with several choices, Special Needs Plans with 56 choices, and Medicare Drug Coverage (Part D) with 9 choices. Each Medicare Advantage Plan has many options, including monthly premium, copayments for primary care, specialists, home care and durable medical equipment, Part B drugs, Part D deductible, Part D drugs, and extra benefits (such as partial coverage for dental care and vision and hearing services). As consumers narrow their choices, they can go online to discover if their doctors are “in-network” and how much their medications might cost. Seniors in other parts of the country face similar layers of complexity and choice.
And if I find this handbook confusing, after 25 years working as a medical director and medical executive for several health insurance companies, how does the average consumer feel? Although Medicare beneficiaries overwhelmingly appreciate their coverage, a 2025 eHealth survey reported that 75 percent said choosing a Medicare plan was confusing. Additionally, 33 percent reported not having a good understanding of the differences among Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Part D plans. An AARP survey found that nearly half of Medicare Advantage beneficiaries did not know whether they could return to traditional Medicare, and more than half did not understand their ability to obtain Medigap coverage afterward.
I understand how the current health insurance system is the result of decades of political compromises about how to structure and pay for health insurance for seniors, but the current process seems to be engineered to produce poor decisions. While the many plan designs and product options appear to provide many choices, the addition of more choices does not always provide value. The psychologist Barry Schwartz wrote about the burdens of excessive choice in his book The Paradox of Choice. He argues that beyond a certain point, additional alternatives can increase the difficulty of decision-making, amplify uncertainty, and leave people less satisfied with the decisions they make.
What are the choices?
The first choice for many people is between traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage. Traditional Medicare generally permits beneficiaries to see any physician or hospital that accepts Medicare. But it has deductibles and coinsurance, does not impose an overall annual limit on out-of-pocket spending for hospital and physician services, and generally requires separate prescription drug coverage. Many beneficiaries purchase Medigap supplemental insurance to reduce their exposure and a separate Part D plan. Medicare Advantage plans, administered by private insurers, generally combine hospital, physician, and prescription drug coverage. They may also provide dental, vision, hearing, and other supplemental benefits. They establish annual limits on out-of-pocket spending for covered medical services. But they can restrict provider networks, require prior authorization, and impose different charges for different services. A more detailed review of Medicare choices is available. A choice made now, during open enrollment, remains in effect for all of 2027.
Real physician voices, twice a week
Free, and one click to unsubscribe.
Embedded in this choice architecture is the assumption that consumers know how much health insurance they need, how much they can afford, and can make appropriate selections. If the purpose of health insurance is to protect against unanticipated medical expenses, how can people be sure they have adequate coverage? Consumers who make mistakes or cannot afford adequate coverage are penalized financially, and medical expenses contribute substantially to bankruptcy. A Kaiser Family Foundation study found that 22 percent of Americans aged 65 and older reported having medical or dental debt. A closer review of the benefit design and financing of health insurance programs has never been adequate coverage.
While Medicare Parts A and B are national programs, Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Medicare Part D plans follow a federal benefit design but are administered by private health insurance plans which operate in regulated marketplaces in each state. Nationally, there are 5,335 Medicare Advantage plans and 316 Medicare Part D plans, and the average beneficiary must choose from among 28 Medicare Advantage plans and 9 Part D plans. Commercial insurance plans are allowed to depart a marketplace when business considerations are not favorable. This year, residents of 193 counties, representing approximately 638,000 Medicare beneficiaries, will have no Medicare Advantage plan available for general enrollment.
Private health insurance companies organize and deliver health insurance services for Medicare Advantage, Medicare Part D, and Medigap within markets in each state. Each plan choice made available by a health insurance company is the product of an actuarial calculation that is based on consideration of the average cost of medical services in a region during the previous year, the expected medical utilization of a population, a medical cost inflation factor, and an additional percentage for overhead expenses and profit. The premium, deductibles, copayment, and coinsurance are calculated in the framework of standard benefit designs and are filed with federal or state governments for approval. The approval process is designed to verify that the insurer will be able to pay benefits outlined in the insurance policy.
How can anyone make a good decision?
The overall framework detailed above is not designed to provide every Medicare beneficiary with the coverage they might need but instead requires each participant to select how much coverage they want based on how much they can afford. The affordability question has two parts: monthly premium expenses, and expected and unexpected deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance for medical and pharmacy expenses in the next year. The unexpected expenses represent a particular challenge. How can anyone anticipate their medical expenses for the next year?
Some people can guess that next year will be at least as expensive as the last one, requiring many of the same types of services, and choose a plan that covers more of their type of expenses. Still, the main purpose of insurance is to help with the unexpected, and serious illnesses can occur suddenly with catastrophic economic consequences.
But how can anyone be expected to estimate their future health care needs? Doesn’t the wide range of choices imply that some people will purchase more insurance than they need and some less? People who are concerned about additional expenses may delay care this year while waiting to purchase better coverage next year. And the consequences of a poor choice may extend beyond a single year. A beneficiary who enrolls in Medicare Advantage and later develops a serious illness may wish to return to traditional Medicare and purchase Medigap coverage. But in many states, after the initial protected enrollment period, insurers may use medical underwriting to deny Medigap coverage or charge more. A decision made while healthy can therefore limit future options when medical needs become greatest.
Each element of the Medicare program (traditional Medicare, Medigap, Medicare Advantage, and Medicare Part D) is rooted in a core principle: Consumers have a choice. You choose your doctor, choose how you want your health care costs to be covered, and how much you want covered. Each choice has consequences and must be balanced against how much you are able to pay. These choices are rooted in the notion that we are all consumers in a marketplace, where doctors, hospitals, and health insurance companies compete with each other for quality and cost. What if we do not like any of the choices available to us, and at what point does the complexity of that choice become prohibitive?
Is there an alternative?
A single-payer system would approach the problem differently. Everyone in the covered population would participate in a common insurance program, with broadly pooled risk and standardized benefits. Instead of choosing among insurers with different networks, formularies, deductibles, and financial limits, patients could concentrate on choosing physicians, hospitals, and treatments. There would be a standardized set of comprehensive benefits based on Medicare rules, but without deductibles, copayment, or coinsurance. All doctors and providers who currently participate in Medicare would participate, and prior approval would be eliminated. Much of the administrative complexity and financial uncertainty that we currently transfer to individual patients would be reduced.
Physicians for a National Health Plan has been advocating for a single-payer approach for decades, and the majority of the population now supports moving in that direction. The basic concept is to eliminate the middleman and liberate the funds used for administration and profit by health insurers to fund better benefits for all consumers and better reimbursement for most doctors. Health insurance companies are required by law to use 85 percent of the premiums they receive for actual medical expenses such as doctors’ fees, medications, and hospitalization. They can retain the remaining 15 percent for their administration and profit. As a basis of comparison, traditional Medicare spends 2 percent on administration. In theory, all the Medicare programs could be administered for substantially less than 15 percent. What do health insurers do with their premium dollars? First, there are shareholders, who receive dividends and the value of stocks which continue to rise. Their well-compensated executives receive bonuses for increasing profit. They employ thousands of workers, and they pay lobbyists and marketing expenses. None of these create value for consumers.
The complexity of decision-making required for Medicare enrollment is overwhelming and often leads to poor choices. For many, good coverage is unaffordable.
Single-payer approaches are not yet available, but you can choose to learn about the possibilities. If you think you would be better off, let your legislators know. For more information on Medicare programs, go to Medicare.gov: Find the plan that works for you.
Edward Anselm is a board-certified internist with a long-standing focus on public health, tobacco control, and preventive care. He earned his medical degree from the Chicago Medical School at Rosalind Franklin University and completed his internal medicine residency at Montefiore Medical Center in New York. Over the past three decades, Dr. Anselm has served in senior leadership roles across clinical, corporate, and managed-care settings, including chief medical officer positions at HIP Health Plan of New York, FidelisCare, and Health Republic Insurance of New York.
Recently retired from his role as medical director at Aetna, Dr. Anselm continues to teach at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai as a clinical assistant professor. His current work focuses on strengthening reimbursement pathways for tobacco cessation and preventive services, helping clinicians integrate evidence-based care that improves patient outcomes while supporting practice sustainability. His research has been published in the American Journal of Accountable Care, the American Journal of Preventive Medicine, AJPM Focus, and Health Affairs Forefront, including articles on tobacco control in accountable care, underbilling of cessation services, and the financial and quality benefits of treating tobacco use as a clinical priority.
Dr. Anselm’s educational and policy work is shared through EdwardAnselmMD.com and Examining Health Insurance Reform | Single Payer: From Debate to Design, with professional updates available on LinkedIn.

