“The American health care system is broken.” For U.S. clinicians, this phrase is as familiar as it is provocative. But what makes the system “broken”? And how might we “repair” it? As a combined emergency and internal medicine resident in the U.S., I had the opportunity to rotate at the International University of Health and Welfare Narita Hospital in Japan for five weeks. My experiences there, from inpatient, to ICU, to the emergency department, felt different than back home: less bloat, delay, and less preoccupation with cost and reimbursement. Curious as to why, I dove into the history, and found that the two health systems reflect generations of political and economic decisions. As we reflect on the historical context, we can examine key contrasts and contemplate possibilities for systemic improvement in the U.S.
Japan’s system originated under the National Health Insurance Act of 1938, which integrated local doctors and municipalities into one system subsidized by the government. Since the 1960s, Japanese citizens have benefited from formal universal health care, whether through employers or the government. National governing standards result in uniform benefits and financing rules.
Insurance in the U.S. started during the Great Depression, when struggling hospitals (traditionally charitable organizations) started selling insurance to stay afloat. President Franklin D. Roosevelt considered adding health insurance to the Social Security Act of 1935, but under pressure from the American Medical Association (AMA) left it out.
By 1945, employers were offering health insurance as a benefit, but only 20 percent of Americans had some form of insurance (compared to 70 percent in Japan). President Truman proposed a universal, compulsory health insurance program, but the AMA launched a huge campaign in opposition, extinguishing Truman’s initiative.
Real physician voices, twice a week
Free, and one click to unsubscribe.
In 1965, Medicare was able to be passed to support coverage for the sicker, elderly population, but no rules were instated regarding prices. Any attempt at government price control was met with strong resistance from the AMA. By 2010, the U.S. had implemented the Affordable Care Act, placing limits on the amount patients can be charged, but price setting and profits remain contentious. Hospitals and physician groups are merging, increasing market power, raising prices and costs (administration is about eight times more expensive in the U.S.). Manufacturers inflate baseline prices of expensive technology and pharmaceuticals to increase profit at the cost of the payer. Forces and incentives run counterproductive to the goal of delivering timely, efficient, and affordable care to the population.
The U.S. system is incohesive, but has its benefits. Market forces push for efficiency and innovation. The U.S. boasts shorter hospital stays with comparable, or better outcomes compared to other countries. The U.S. also has access to cutting-edge treatment, drug, procedural, and diagnostic technology. Private insurance institutes prior authorization and gatekeeping to manage utilization of expensive tests, specialist visits, and costly interventions, aiming at efficient and appropriate allotment of resources, a practice adapted in other countries. Unfortunately, it’s unclear whether these actually result in equitable allocation of resources. Those who navigate the system successfully may access advanced therapies (something often impossible in single-payer systems), but there is disparity in ability to navigate the system.
Disparity is distinct from the economics of the U.S. system, but an important driver of health outcomes. Life expectancy varies by decades between zip codes, and comorbidity rates are higher in underserved populations, contributing to the U.S.’s below-average life expectancy, maternal and fetal mortality rates, and prevalence of chronic disease. Social determinants of health (neighborhood, income, and education) intersect with the decentralized system to produce outcomes disproportionately poor when compared with other countries.
In summary, the U.S. has an incohesive system operating within the context of generations of disparity. A single-payer system could theoretically be implemented, but historical institutions make it unrealistic for the U.S. to “start over” with a centralized foundation. Also, single-payer may slow innovation, or restrict access to new treatments.
However, other aspects of Japanese health care may offer a model for reform in the U.S. Preventative and primary care is a focus where the U.S. system struggles to deliver. In Japan, patients are mandated to participate in “Kenko Shindan” appointments at specialized centers that focus on preventative health. These visits address everything from eyesight and hearing, to metabolic syndrome, dementia, and cancer screenings. There are also optional checkups, called “Ningen Dock,” focusing on early detection of asymptomatic chronic disease, early stage cancers, and obesity-related disease. These institutions address population and preventative health, and give primary care providers (PCPs) bandwidth to focus on acute complaints or chronic conditions. Testing and diagnostics are also streamlined. Labs or imaging ordered during a visit will result before the appointment is concluded. PCPs don’t follow up results on an unpredictable timeline, or make additional phone calls or appointments to address results. One PCP in Japan may see 50-80 patients per day, taking only 5-10 minutes per encounter (contrasted with up to 20 patients per day seen by a U.S. PCP).
The scope and efficiency of PCP clinics allow them, in turn, to offload patient volume from hospitals and EDs. Overcrowding is a major problem affecting health care systems. Lack of access to primary care is often cited as a reason for ED overutilization, with one study reporting over half of ED visits examined could be primary care-eligible. Japan’s network of acute care centers and prehospital triage allows emergency medical services to transport patients to appropriate levels of care, ranging from facilities for walk-ins without in-hospital services, to emergency facilities with capacity to stabilize, admit, and treat the critically ill. Japan provides access to preventative care, acute primary care, emergency transport to appropriate acute care, or timely evaluation in an emergency center as appropriate, striving to allocate resources appropriately and efficiently, combating hospital bloat, overcrowding, and long wait times.
Understanding how historical, cultural, and economic factors shape health systems can illuminate paths toward more accessible, sustainable, and equitable systems of care. Apart from insurance and reimbursement reform, there are lessons in delivery of preventative care and triage that we may learn from other systems like Japan’s.
Patricia E. Simmer and Kazuki Toda are emergency medicine and internal medicine residents.


