As physicians, we are trained to recognize illness, provide treatment, support recovery, and approach our patients with compassion. We understand that a diagnosis does not define a person and that successful treatment requires more than simply addressing the immediate symptoms of disease.
Yet when physicians themselves develop substance use disorders, our profession too often responds through a framework centered on discipline rather than rehabilitation. California has an opportunity to change that.
I am an obstetrician-gynecologist who has practiced medicine for more than twenty years. In 2020, I developed alcohol use disorder. My illness resulted in hospitalization, the loss of my employment, and disciplinary action by the Medical Board of California.
I entered recovery in 2021 and have remained continuously sober since February 9 of that year. For more than five and a half years, I have participated in extensive monitoring without a single positive substance test.
Real physician voices, twice a week
Free, and one click to unsubscribe.
My experience has led me to consider a larger question: Why do we recognize substance use disorder as a treatable medical condition in our patients, yet struggle to apply that same understanding to physicians who experience it?
Recovery and accountability can coexist
The Medical Board has an essential responsibility to protect the public. Physicians whose substance use places patients at risk must be identified, evaluated, treated, and appropriately monitored. Compassion does not require overlooking unsafe behavior. Nor should a diagnosis of substance use disorder excuse professional misconduct.
But accountability and rehabilitation should not be mutually exclusive. We routinely care for patients with chronic medical conditions that require prolonged treatment, monitoring, and behavioral change. We recognize progress, adjust treatment based on clinical evidence, and support patients as they regain stability and function.
Physicians recovering from substance use disorders deserve an equally thoughtful, individualized approach. Sustained sobriety, adherence to treatment, consistently negative testing, and demonstrated fitness to practice should meaningfully inform decisions about monitoring requirements and professional reintegration. A system that recognizes recovery must also provide a realistic pathway toward restoration.
The unintended consequences of prolonged disciplinary probation
California discontinued its Physician Diversion Program in 2008 following documented deficiencies in oversight and monitoring. Those failures raised legitimate patient safety concerns and must inform any future program.
However, eliminating diversion did not eliminate substance use disorders among physicians. It removed a dedicated framework intended to combine rehabilitation with public protection. Under the current disciplinary system, physicians may face significant obstacles to returning to clinical practice even after years of documented recovery.
Probationary licenses can create barriers to credentialing and employment. Workplace monitoring, restrictions on clinical responsibilities, and disclosure requirements may discourage employers from hiring otherwise qualified physicians. In some cases, probation requires qualifying clinical employment for completion. When physicians cannot secure such employment, their probationary periods may be extended. This creates a troubling contradiction: The restrictions intended to ensure safe professional reintegration can also prevent that reintegration from occurring.
These consequences affect more than individual physicians. They can deprive communities of experienced clinicians at a time when access to health care remains a significant concern. The financial costs of prolonged monitoring, testing, and administrative requirements can further complicate recovery, particularly when physicians are unable to maintain employment. A regulatory framework should be rigorous, but it should also be designed to produce measurable progress toward safe practice.
Physician health is a patient safety issue
Physicians are not immune to addiction, depression, or psychological distress. Yet the culture of medicine has historically emphasized endurance, competence, and self-reliance. Physicians may fear that acknowledging illness or seeking treatment will threaten their careers, professional reputations, or medical licenses.
When the consequences of disclosure appear overwhelmingly punitive, physicians may become less willing to seek help early. That possibility should concern everyone committed to patient safety. A system that encourages early identification, confidential assessment when appropriate, effective treatment, and ongoing monitoring can support both physician well-being and public protection.
We should also recognize the profound isolation that can accompany professional exclusion. Medicine is not simply employment for many physicians. It represents years of education, professional relationships, service, and identity. Supporting a physician’s recovery includes recognizing the importance of meaningful professional reintegration when it can be accomplished safely.
A better approach for California
California should establish a modern Physician Diversion Program grounded in evidence-based addiction treatment, independent oversight, and clearly defined patient safety standards. Such a program should include comprehensive clinical evaluations, individualized monitoring, access to treatment, and transparent criteria for progression and successful completion.
It should provide structured return-to-practice pathways and collaborate with employers and credentialing organizations to create appropriate opportunities for supervised clinical work. It must also incorporate the lessons of California’s former program, including independent auditing, reliable testing, prompt intervention when safety concerns arise, and meaningful accountability.
Importantly, the program should recognize sustained recovery as clinically significant. Monitoring requirements should reflect demonstrated risk, treatment progress, and fitness to practice rather than relying solely on the passage of time or fixed disciplinary conditions.
Extending compassion to our own profession
For more than five and a half years, I have remained sober while participating in monitoring, psychiatric care, and physician recovery programs. I understand the seriousness of my illness and the responsibility that accompanies the privilege of practicing medicine.
I also understand, both as a physician and as someone in recovery, that treatment works, that people can change, and that recovery deserves recognition. My experience is only one among many. Physicians across specialties and backgrounds face substance use disorders, and those who seek treatment and demonstrate sustained recovery should have access to a fair, clinically informed pathway back to their profession.
We would never tell a patient that successful treatment is irrelevant because of the diagnosis that brought them into care. We should not communicate that message to physicians.
California can protect patients without abandoning physicians who become patients themselves. Reinstating a carefully designed Physician Diversion Program would affirm that accountability, compassion, rehabilitation, and public safety belong within the same framework.
Medicine asks us to believe in the possibility of recovery. It is time we extend that belief to one another.
Ruth Hahn is an obstetrician-gynecologist.

