Earlier this year, I was listening to an episode of The Podcast by KevinMD during which the guest Dr. Andrea Hayes spoke about her “second act” as a writer after retirement from clinical medicine. As a physician who has rediscovered an interest in writing in the last few years, my ears perked up.
On the surface, our careers had followed different paths: Dr. Hayes had been a private practice endocrinologist before entering concierge medicine and then finally “retiring” into a new career as a writer. I’m an academic pulmonary and critical care physician with no near-term designs on stepping away from the bedside.
But at one point in the episode, I heard two phrases that resonated deeply. The first was, “I didn’t lose myself in medicine.” Hayes had cultivated a life outside of work and therefore faced less of an identity crisis when she chose to leave clinical practice.
Her second, more impactful phrase was, “I felt like I had done enough.” That one stopped me. It’s a question I’ve grappled with personally, and it’s one I’ve observed almost every other physician struggle with, too: What is enough? How do we know when we’ve done enough? Can it be enough to “just” practice medicine?
Real physician voices, twice a week
Free, and one click to unsubscribe.
Between March of 2025 and March of 2026, I was on medical leave for a total of nearly five months, due to a one-two punch of an influenza hospitalization and a rotator cuff repair. That time on leave left me with plenty of headspace. One question kept surfacing: Am I doing enough?
There is a certain absurdity in that question. I’m a critical care physician, a clinical well-being leader, and an associate professor. More importantly, I’m a husband, and my wife and I have four school-aged children. Apparently not content with the chaos of creating four humans, we also have four guinea pigs.
And yet, in moments alone (and in therapy), I still found myself asking whether I was doing enough. Ironically, at the same time, I sometimes asked myself whether I was doing too much. Of course, those questions are intertwined: Too much at work can mean not enough at home, and vice versa. Every decision, every commitment, carries opportunity costs.
Maybe the deeper issue is that enough is often defined for us, in relation to some external benchmark. If we allow ourselves to define those goals for ourselves, we can more easily align the life we create with one that feels like enough. But if we allow others to define our goals for us, we’re more likely to end up misaligned.
Early in our careers, the definition of enough can feel quite literal. It’s often codified in regulations. There are milestones. Evaluations. In-training exams. Interviews. Match Day. Boards. We’re subject to a tempting fallacy: Once I’ve done enough, I will arrive. I will be complete. Fully formed.
Then we become attendings, and the fallacy of that story becomes evident. Sometimes slowly. Sometimes in a flash.
As we age, nearly all physicians experience a transition in who defines enough on our behalf. Maybe it’s a concrete person (a division chief or department chair) or even the more nebulous “culture of medicine.” Maybe it’s some younger version of ourselves, someone with grand designs on professional achievement before we fully understood their potential cost.
That voice of our younger selves can show up at home, too (for example, in the disconnect between how we thought parenthood would look and how it feels in practice). Perhaps part of the problem arises from our tendency to define enough in relation to the curated version of professional and personal life we see depicted on social media.
We risk conflating two questions: “Am I doing enough?” and “Am I enough?” The first is about productivity and action. The second is existential. The danger lies in answering the second question using the gaps we might identify with the first, particularly when we ignore domain separation and tradeoffs. Because we can never really do enough everywhere or for everyone.
I’ve structured my professional life to let me be far more present at home than many mid-career critical care physicians, particularly in comparison to prior generations. But my kids are still (fortunately) upset when I’m on call during a school event. They’re still frustrated when I’m in the unit on a Saturday, but they want to go to the pool.
Our professional lives share properties with gaseous states: They fill the spaces they’re given and will expand infinitely if allowed to do so. We must define their boundaries.
This leaves us with many questions. What is enough? Who gets to decide what enough means in my life? Can I be enough, even if I’m not doing enough in someone else’s eyes?
I’m not going to pretend for a second that I’ve figured it out. But when I’m faced with the question “Am I doing enough?” perhaps the right response isn’t to deliver an answer, but to ask another question instead: “Who’s asking?”
Ian Barbash is a practicing clinician, leader, and writer. He is an associate professor of medicine at the University of Pittsburgh and a pulmonary and critical care attending physician at UPMC. He graduated from Williams College and Harvard Medical School before completing residency at Massachusetts General Hospital and fellowship in Pittsburgh, where he remains on faculty and lives with his wife and four children.
In addition to his clinical work, he completed training grants from the National Institutes of Health and the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, led an ICU telemedicine program during COVID-19, and currently leads physician well-being programs. With a career spanning clinical care, leadership, academic research, and physician well-being, he brings a unique perspective to storytelling in medicine.
His writing spans critical care health services research and narrative medicine, with work appearing in JAMA, NEJM Catalyst, and Annals of Internal Medicine. His memoir, In the Unit, explores his experience with critical illness as both a patient and an ICU survivor. He writes and speaks about that experience to promote empathy for both health care professionals and the people they serve. He shares more on his website and on Substack.



