Listen and followApple PodcastsSpotifyYouTubeMore apps · Browse all episodes
“Yes, the opioid crisis in this country has caused a reckoning in the medical field about how to treat patient pain. Ignoring the pain will not make it go away.
Options are available beyond opioids, and policymakers and health care providers need to be aware that attention to effective health care practices must move beyond silencing to solutions.”
Layla Parast is a statistician.
She shares her story and discusses her KevinMD article, “It’s time to address pain despite the opioid crisis.”
The Podcast by KevinMD is brought to you by the Nuance Dragon Ambient eXperience.
With a growing physician shortage, increasing burnout, and declining patient satisfaction, a dramatic change is needed to make health care more efficient and effective and bring back the joy of practicing medicine. AI-driven ambient clinical intelligence promises to help by revolutionizing patient and provider experiences with clinical documentation that writes itself.
The Nuance Dragon Ambient eXperience, or DAX for short, is a voice-enabled, ambient clinical intelligence solution that automatically captures patient encounters securely and accurately at the point of care. Physicians who use DAX have reported a 50 percent decrease in documentation time and a 70 percent reduction in feelings of burnout, and 83 percent of patients say their physician is more personable and conversational.
Rediscover the joy of medicine with clinical documentation that writes itself, all within the EHR.
VISIT SPONSOR → https://nuance.com/daxinaction
SUBSCRIBE TO THE PODCAST → https://kevinmd.com/podcast
RATE AND REVIEW → https://kevinmd.com/rate
FOLLOW ON INSTAGRAM → https://www.instagram.com/kevinphomd
FOLLOW ON TIKTOK → https://www.tiktok.com/@kevinphomd
GET CME FOR THIS EPISODE → https://earnc.me/sxOqAR
Powered by CMEfy.
Transcript
Kevin Pho: Hi, and welcome to the show, where we share the stories of the many who intersect with our health care system but are rarely heard from. My name is Kevin Pho, founder and editor of KevinMD. Rate and review the show at kevinmd.com/rate. Subscribe at kevinmd.com/podcast. Today on the show we have Layla Parast. She’s a statistician, and her KevinMD article is titled “It’s time to address pain despite the opioid crisis.” Layla, welcome to the show.
Layla Parast: Thank you. Thank you for having me.
Kevin Pho: So we’ll get into the article a little bit, but first off, briefly share your story and journey to where you are today.
Layla Parast: Sure. I am an associate professor in the Department of Statistics and Data Science at the University of Texas at Austin. Before this, I was a statistician at the RAND Corporation, which is a nonprofit think tank out in California. I was there for 10 years, loved it, but needed it. And before that, I was in school. I have my PhD in biostatistics from Harvard and a master’s in statistics from Stanford, so I am definitely very statistics-trained.
Real physician voices, twice a week
Free, and one click to unsubscribe.
Kevin Pho: So regarding the intersection between health care data and statistics, a lot of the lay public, and a lot of physicians for that matter, sometimes we have trouble interpreting the data. So tell us about that intersection between health care statistics and areas where you think that we can improve when it comes to interpreting health care statistics.
Layla Parast: At RAND I learned a lot about that. My training in graduate school was very much methods-focused and not on presenting or communicating with non-statisticians. At RAND I had the opportunity to communicate with all kinds of people, physicians and senior researchers who are very smart and very good at what they do, but they are not experts in statistics, just like I am not an expert in medicine. So it was about being able to explain the results and concepts to them, and being able to explain results of very complicated analyses to people in government who are going to make very important decisions based on what you say. If they don’t understand what you’re saying, it doesn’t really matter how great your analyses are.
So that was very humbling for me, and it was a long journey to learn how to communicate with them and to learn that if someone doesn’t understand what you’re saying, you need to try a different way. You can’t just keep repeating it in the same way. What’s the standard deviation? Things like that seem so simple to me, but they’re not.
And in communicating with the public, we certainly had to write a lot of communication that was meant for patients, providers, and other stakeholders, and again had to take very complicated statistical concepts and make them transparent and understandable.
Kevin Pho: Now, for those of us who don’t have degrees in statistics, and it could be patients, it could be clinicians, if we want to get better at interpreting studies and just get better at statistics in general, what are some easy ways that we can do that?
Layla Parast: I feel like there are so many books now that aim to do exactly that, nonfiction books that are trying to take these very complex statistical concepts and explain them to regular people who are very smart in their own right. I have found those very helpful myself, so I recommend those.
Honestly, this maybe sounds very silly, but YouTube has so many great videos. My goodness. This semester I am teaching freshmen, and I’m teaching them introduction to data science, which has been very fun. But there were some things in the curriculum that I didn’t know how to do, like web scraping. I’ve never scraped data from the web, so I had to learn how to do it, and I learned by watching YouTube videos. They showed me how to go through the R code and how to find the HTML tags. It was pretty incredible. It’s incredible what’s out there. I just taught that to them yesterday and told them myself, “Let me be honest, I learned this on YouTube.”
So there are so many great resources. Professors make a lot of videos online, and honestly, their YouTube videos are better than their in-person classes, because they have to make them short and clear and punchy, and it gives people an incentive to make great content.
Kevin Pho: Let me ask one other statistics-related question, because honestly, we don’t have very many statisticians on the show, so I wanted to take advantage of this, and then we’ll get to your article. Now, if you’re reading some type of statistics in the lay press, what are some red flags that we should look out for, just to give us a sense of, “Hey, maybe we shouldn’t quite trust this interpretation”? Any red flags that we should look out for whenever we read about statistics on the internet, for instance?
Layla Parast: My biggest red flag is when you read anything that is talking about an intervention or comparing two groups based on some characteristic, and then they conclude that whatever analysis they did implies something causal.
One that I’ve had a lot of experience with is this: We took households that have pets, and then we took households that don’t have pets, and we looked at the kids, at the physical health and the emotional health of those kids. The kids in the households with pets were healthier physically and emotionally than those without pets. You will find so many articles that will take a study like that and say, “Oh, pets improve a child’s physical and emotional health.” And that feels right. I grew up with a dog. Yeah, that must be true.
But we have done that analysis using this huge household survey in California, and it was true that when you compare those two types of households, that’s what you see. Households with pets are also much more likely to be white, to have parents that are working full time, to have higher income, and all kinds of other characteristics that are also associated with better physical and emotional health, good or bad. And once you account for those differences, there is no effect of pets on children’s physical and emotional health, at least in our analysis.
So that is my biggest thing. When I read something and it says, “We compared these two groups, and because we saw this difference, that means you should take vitamin E every day, that means you should drink coffee, that means you should stop drinking coffee,” did you account for all of the other things that are different between the two groups? I see that over and over, and I think that it’s very convincing if you don’t know to look for that.
Kevin Pho: All right, let’s talk about your KevinMD article now. OK, I’m going to change topics here. It’s titled “It’s time to address pain despite the opioid crisis.” Now, for those of you who get a chance to read your article, just walk my audience through it. Share the story of why you decided to write it.
Layla Parast: Sure. I am a fellow of the Public Voices OpEd Project. It’s a yearlong fellowship geared toward women and minorities to get our voices out, and we were encouraged to think about something that we felt we were experts in and also felt very passionate about. This topic of pain immediately came to mind for me.
When I was at RAND, I worked for 10 years on several projects related to patient experience surveys. You go to the hospital, you’re discharged, you come home, and you’re very likely going to get this HCAHPS survey, a survey about your experience in the hospital. To be honest, when I first started working on these projects, I thought, “Who cares if your doctor’s nice to you? Does that matter? Doesn’t it just matter if they make sure you don’t die and cure you and things like that?” So I definitely was not a believer in the beginning, but I completely changed over my 10 years working there.
Numerous studies have shown that patient experience does matter. Patients are more likely to fill their prescriptions, to follow their follow-up care guidelines, and to come back to the doctor when they’re supposed to if their doctor was nice to them and listened to them and treated them with respect. Anecdotally, I see it in my dad, I see it in my friends. You don’t want to go to a doctor that isn’t pleasant. I know there’s this argument that those are not hotel rooms, that it’s not supposed to be a nice experience to be in the hospital, and that’s true. No, health care is not fun. No one looks forward to it. But that doesn’t mean you can’t expect to be listened to and treated with respect.
So patient experience in general has been something that I worked on a lot. I was a statistician on several projects, and then I led a very large project funded by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to develop and test the patient experience survey in the emergency department setting. There was not a CMS-implemented patient experience survey in the ED setting, and so we were tasked with developing it and testing it. A huge part of that survey was pain questions. Pain is very important to patients, especially in the emergency room. People go to the emergency room if they think they’re going to die, if they’re scared, or if they’re in pain and have nowhere else to go. So we spent a lot of time working with focus groups and doing cognitive testing, in English and in Spanish, of pain questions.
When the opioid crisis started, and it’s ongoing, not surprisingly, there was a lot of public discussion around whether having questions around pain and prescriptions for pain on a survey incentivizes doctors to overprescribe opioids in particular. Results from these kinds of surveys are typically publicly reported, and they inform payment in some settings. So it was very political.
I worked very hard with my team and with CMS to test new pain questions that were not about prescriptions for pain but were instead about communication about pain. So it was asking the patient: Did your doctor talk with you about pain? Did they ask you about how much pain you were in? Did they talk with you about managing your pain when you got home? There was nothing about, “Did you get a prescription?” We changed the questions on the survey, but the political pressure on CMS, and I do not speak for CMS at all, I don’t work for CMS, but the political pressure on them to completely remove those questions from the survey was immense. And so they did remove them.
Kevin Pho: Who was pressuring them to remove those questions?
Layla Parast: Physician groups and Congress. Those are the big ones that we saw documentation of, and I linked to it in my article. Very much physician groups. So yeah, the ultimate pressure came from Congress.
Kevin Pho: And was it because of the perception that these questions implicitly pressure doctors to prescribe more opioids?
Layla Parast: Yes, yes. There have been numerous studies analyzing the association between responses to these questions and opioid prescribing and not finding a link. So there was no evidence that there was a link. It was just this pressure.
Kevin Pho: OK, so where do we stand now?
Layla Parast: The questions are not on the survey at all, on any of the surveys. They were completely taken off, and that’s where we are now. I’m not at RAND, so I don’t work on that project anymore, but it just seems astounding to me to have surveys about someone’s experience in the hospital, whether inpatient or ED, and not talk about pain. Pain is a huge component of your experience in the hospital.
That doesn’t mean it needs to be publicly reported. It doesn’t mean you pay providers based on the responses to those questions. But I think we should be asking those questions. I think we should measure it. How can we look at things like racial disparities and gender disparities in pain management if we don’t even ask those questions? It’s not enough to just look at prescriptions in the EHR, looking at prescriptions to look at disparities. That’s not what we’re talking about. So it’s a huge loss to me that they were taken off the survey, and that was the message that I wanted to get out there.
Kevin Pho: So you’re proposing an obviously much more nuanced approach to asking pain questions, and you must feel that you have to thread a needle here, because this is a heavily politicized issue. So give me some examples of some questions that you would ask patients in regard to pain.
Layla Parast: The questions that we tested worked well. And by worked well, I mean we do cognitive testing of survey items to make sure that patients with different educational levels and language levels can understand the questions similarly and respond similarly. A simple question is the one that I mentioned: Did doctors and nurses talk to you about your pain? That’s it. And the response options are “Yes, definitely,” “Yes, somewhat,” and “No.” That’s it. Did doctors or nurses, or you can say did hospital staff, talk with you about how to manage your pain when you got home? I don’t think those are controversial questions.
We did test some questions that were around alternatives to prescriptions. Did hospital staff talk with you about ways you could manage your pain besides prescriptions? And then there was a checklist: Did they talk to you about ice packs, heating pads, acupuncture, stretches, all kinds of different things? Did hospital staff talk with you about potential side effects and risks of any prescriptions for pain that you were prescribed?
So that one was really trying to get at if an opioid was prescribed. You can’t use the word “opioid” on a survey. People don’t know that. We know what that is, but the general public does not know what that is. It’s very confusing, and you can’t use brand names. So it was trying to get at whether risk of addiction was even discussed with them. Those questions were a little bit harder for people to interpret, so we stayed away from those questions. But those first two I mentioned, I think, are benign and still very helpful questions in terms of measuring what’s going on around pain in the hospital.
Kevin Pho: What are your thoughts about these patient experience surveys being linked in many cases to a physician’s pay?
Layla Parast: Yeah, oh, it’s such a controversial topic. If I was a doctor, I would not like it. That being said, as a professor, the reviews my students give me are linked to my promotion, heavily linked. Even those open-ended questions that they asked them, they’re reviewed when you go up for tenure, when you go up for full professor, and every year when you’re reviewed. That’s a little bit scary, right? A random upset student who just wants to maybe get back at you can really impact your career. Hopefully that doesn’t happen. In a small way, I know what that feels like.
I think it’s a very touchy area, right? I, again, am not a doctor, but I assume that doctors became doctors to save lives, to make people healthier, not necessarily to be like a receptionist and to just be nice. You should be able to be a wonderful, successful doctor even if you’re not that nice. I can see that argument. But again, because there have been studies that show that patient experience matters to patients, it’s hard to ignore that patients are humans. We’re not necessarily going to do what you tell us to do if you’re not nice about it. So there’s this human aspect that is hard to ignore.
Kevin Pho: We’re talking to Layla Parast. She’s a statistician. Her KevinMD article is titled “It’s time to address pain despite the opioid crisis.” What are some of the take-home messages that you want to leave with the KevinMD audience?
Layla Parast: Take-home messages, I would say, would be: Be patient, be patient. That we are flawed, and that kindness will make us do the things that we’re supposed to do, is something that is just true, and it’s important.
Kevin Pho: Well, thank you so much for sharing your time and insight, and thanks again for being on the show.
Layla Parast: Thank you.
Listen and followApple PodcastsSpotifyYouTubeMore apps · Browse all episodes


