When physicians tell me why they waited so long to start therapy, the answer is rarely “I didn’t think I needed it.” It is usually a question they could not get a straight answer to: If I see someone, where does that information go?
The fear is not irrational. In a 2017 Mayo Clinic Proceedings study of 5,829 physicians, nearly 40 percent said they would be reluctant to seek formal care for a mental health condition because of concerns about their medical license. The same study found that only about a third of states asked licensing questions limited to current impairment. Among 297 physicians who sought therapy through the Cerevity network in 2026, 61 percent said they had delayed care over licensing fears, and the median delay was 22 months.
Twenty-two months is a long time to practice medicine while struggling. And much of that delay comes from uncertainty, not from any actual rule. So here is a plain map of the four places a therapy record can travel, and the questions worth asking before you book.
1. The insurance claim
When therapy is billed to insurance, the therapist submits a claim with a diagnosis code. The plan stores it. An explanation of benefits goes to the policyholder, which matters if you are on a spouse’s or parent’s plan. For most physicians this is not a disaster. But it is the trail many are thinking about when they hesitate, and it is worth knowing it exists.
Real physician voices, twice a week
Free, and one click to unsubscribe.
Ask: Will this be billed to my plan? Who receives the explanation of benefits?
2. The employer’s program
Hospital and group employee assistance programs (EAPs) are generally confidential in the sense that your employer does not receive session content. But the program is sponsored by the institution you work for, it often caps the number of sessions, and in a smaller system the counselor may be someone you will see at the next grand rounds. Many physicians never call for those reasons alone.
Ask: Who runs this program? What, if anything, does my employer receive? How many sessions are covered?
3. The licensing and credentialing forms
This is the fear behind most of the others. Read the actual questions on your state license renewal and your hospital credentialing application, not the version passed down by a senior resident. Many questions focus on current conditions that impair your ability to practice. Seeing a therapist for burnout, grief, or anxiety that is being managed is a different thing from current impairment. If a question is ambiguous, physician health program staff, your malpractice carrier, or an attorney can tell you how it is read in your state.
Ask: What exactly does this form ask, and over what time period?
4. The therapist’s own record
Every licensed clinician keeps records, and those records are protected by professional confidentiality rules and, in legal settings, by psychotherapist privilege. When you see an independent licensed clinician you choose yourself and pay directly, there is no employer involvement and no insurance claim. The record stays with the clinician. That is why many physicians who would never use an EAP or bill insurance are willing to start therapy privately.
Ask: Where are my records kept? Who could ever see them, and under what circumstances?
What confidentiality has to look like
For physicians to actually use care, “confidential” has to mean something concrete. It means a clear answer, in writing, about where information goes. It means scheduling that works around a call schedule, including early mornings, evenings, and video sessions. And it means a clinician who understands medical culture well enough that the physician does not spend the first three sessions explaining what a 28-hour shift does to a person.
Institutions can help too. Hospitals that publish a plain-language explanation of what their EAP does and does not share, and that review their credentialing questions so they ask only about current impairment, remove two of the biggest reasons physicians stay away.
If you have been waiting for a sign, consider this one: The uncertainty is usually worse than the reality. Find out where the record goes. Then make the call.
Martha Fernandez is a licensed clinical social worker.
Your KevinMD author page is one of the top results for your name. Turn it into a premium profile, publish in 1 to 3 days, and get a guaranteed podcast slot.
