Last year around this time, a student offered me $1,000 to write the personal statement for their residency application.
Not to coach them through exercises that would help them write it themselves. Not to edit a finished draft. One thousand dollars for me to write 800 words about their life that they could submit alongside their transcripts and Dean’s Letter to the Electronic Residency Application Service (ERAS).
At first, it would have been easy to interpret this request as laziness, entitlement, or an early symptom of the burgeoning AI era (I have more to say on that in another essay). If I’m honest, I was truly irritated and unimpressed when I read the email. The request felt fundamentally misaligned with the humanity-in-medicine work that I stand for. Didn’t they understand that outsourcing their essay felt like cheating not only the application process, but themselves?
The purpose of the personal statement is to help residency programs understand who an applicant is beyond grades, test scores, and CV entries. It is meant to offer insight into motivation, perspective, communication, and professional identity. In a process where applicants can begin to blur together academically, the essay is one of the few places students can reveal something distinctly human about themselves. Why would someone give that opportunity away?
I scheduled a meeting with the student because I wanted to understand the request more deeply. To their credit, they showed up honestly and with vulnerability. This student wasn’t blowing off the essay. They were afraid of it. I know what medical training does to a person’s courage.
Sitting with my own reactions a bit longer, I realized the barrier for this student was not writing. The barrier was identity. The personal statement asks a question many medical trainees have spent years avoiding: Who am I, in medicine and outside of it?
I run personal statement workshops for medical students applying to residency programs. Some students assume these workshops are about grammar, structure, or strategy. They are not. I will not spend any time turning your colons into em dashes (or is it vice versa? I’m not sure). I am much more interested in helping students remember themselves and recognize what is actually alive and human in their stories.
The struggles that students commonly bring into these workshops have very little to do with writing itself. They are afraid of sounding unimpressive. They do not know what “counts” as meaningful. They are trying to sound like who they think admissions wants. They have spent so many years performing competence that they no longer know how to describe themselves outside of achievement. When students sit down in front of a blank document, what emerges is identity uncertainty masquerading as writer’s block.
The personal statement asks students to move from accomplishment to meaning. From performance to perspective. From résumé to reflection. That is difficult work.
Students often assume strong personal statements come from the most impressive experiences or the most polished writing. But the strongest statements are usually built from the most honestly understood moments. A student writes about translating for their grandparents at medical appointments. Another writes about repairing bicycles between classes because it was the only place their mind became quiet. Another realizes halfway through a workshop that the reason they love emergency medicine is not adrenaline, but the privilege of helping families tolerate uncertainty.
These are not necessarily extraordinary experiences. Yet, they become powerful when the writer understands what they mean. And medicine desperately needs clinicians who know themselves.
In my workshops, I often ask students questions that have nothing to do with medicine at all:
- What makes you lose track of time entirely?
- What kind of complexity do you actually enjoy?
- What did you love before you learned what was professionally acceptable?
- What do people consistently seek you out for help with?
These questions matter because many trainees have spent years becoming excellent test-takers, learning how to identify the one best answer choice, and functioning as reliable, interchangeable components of a system. This is how the medical system, and the way we educate students to become a part of it, works. It may seem inevitable that somewhere along the way, trainees lose access to the person underneath the performance. Yet, under the years of evaluations, competencies, and metrics, there is still a human being with actual curiosities, talents, values, and ways of seeing the world.
ADVERTISEMENT
Medicine does not need fewer of those qualities right now. It needs more. I don’t actually know what happened to the student who offered me $1,000 to write their personal statement, but I have thought about that conversation many times since because versions of that same fear appear in nearly every workshop I teach.
Recently, one student in particular, someone I know very well, kept removing themselves from every draft they wrote. Each version became more polished, more professional, and somehow less alive. Every time they revised, they seemed to drift further away from their own voice.
And every time, I found myself saying the same thing: Put yourself back into this. Stop writing what you think residency programs want to hear and start writing what is actually true. The night before they submitted, they finally listened.
Recently, I ran into that student again. They had matched into PM&R, their specialty of choice. And one of their interviewers had specifically thanked them for their personal statement.
Not because it was perfect. Not because it sounded impressive. Because it sounded real.
That is what many students misunderstand about the residency personal statement. The goal is not flawless writing. The goal is learning to recognize yourself clearly enough to be honest.
And that is something medical education should spend far more time teaching all of us how to do.
This article is discussed on The Podcast by KevinMD in the episode Medical students aren’t cheating on their essays: They’re afraid.
Kathleen Muldoon is a certified coach dedicated to empowering authenticity and humanity in health care. She is a professor in the College of Graduate Studies at Midwestern University – Glendale, where she pioneered innovative courses such as humanity in medicine, medical improv, and narrative medicine. An award-winning educator, Dr. Muldoon was named the 2023 National Educator of the Year by the Student Osteopathic Medical Association. Her personal experiences with disability sparked a deep interest in communication science and public health. She has delivered over 200 seminars and workshops globally and serves on academic and state committees advocating for patient- and professional-centered care. Dr. Muldoon is co-founder of Stop CMV AZ/Alto CMV AZ, fostering partnerships among health care providers, caregivers, and vulnerable communities. Her expertise has been featured on NPR, USA Today, and multiple podcasts. She shares insights and resources through Linktree, Instagram, Substack, and LinkedIn, and her academic work includes a featured publication in The Anatomical Record.
