In March 2020, medicine achieved something policy experts thought would take decades: millions of outpatient visits moved online almost overnight. Before COVID-19, telehealth made up about 1 percent or less of outpatient care, and just 0.3 percent among commercially insured adults in early 2019. Strict geographic rules and poor reimbursement limited its use. However, by April 2020, telehealth jumped to over 40 percent of Medicare primary care visits, as clinicians quickly adapted even before payment parity was in place.
Now that the emergency phase has passed, telehealth has leveled off at about 4 to 12 percent of visits, depending on the health system and patient group. As the novelty fades, post-pandemic research gives us a clearer, more detailed view of what virtual care can do. Telehealth works well when used for the right clinical problems. But when used for everything, it can create new blind spots for patients and overwhelming inbox burdens for clinicians.
Many large studies show a clear result. For conditions that depend on conversation, taking a patient’s history, and ongoing follow-up instead of a physical exam, telehealth is as good as or better than traditional office visits.
Mental health remains the undisputed anchor of virtual care, showing high satisfaction, fewer missed appointments, and virtually no difference in downstream emergency visits compared to office care. Telehealth’s biggest clinical success may be in addiction medicine. Research on insured patients starting buprenorphine, published in the Journal of General Internal Medicine, found that starting treatment through telehealth led to higher retention, more consistent refills, and a 36 percent lower overdose rate compared to starting in person. Federal policy now permanently allows audio-only buprenorphine initiation, under a rule that took effect at the end of 2025.
Real physician voices, twice a week
Free, and one click to unsubscribe.
In contrast, telehealth struggles with acute, unclear complaints and with preventive care. Large primary care studies, such as an analysis of over 2.3 million visits in Annals of Internal Medicine and a Journal of General Internal Medicine analysis of 2022 visits in a Midwest health system, show that virtual visits for acute issues lead to much higher rates of seven-day in-person follow-up than office visits. When a patient calls with acute abdominal pain, a sore throat, or ear pain, clinicians cannot examine the abdomen, swab for strep, or look in the ear, which creates diagnostic uncertainty.
That uncertainty has notable effects. Recent data show that antibiotics are prescribed more often during video and phone visits than during in-person exams. This has led health systems and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to reconsider whether conditions like pharyngitis and ear infections should be evaluated virtually. Also, replacing routine office visits with virtual ones means fewer blood pressure checks, missed cancer screenings, and delayed lab work.
For clinicians, telehealth has both benefits and drawbacks. Hybrid schedules and remote days have improved work-life balance, given useful insights into patients’ home environments, and helped keep physicians in their jobs. Doctor burnout is not caused by video visits, but by the electronic inbox that grew with them. Between 2020 and 2025, patient portal messages increased by 153 percent, according to national data published in JAMA. Messaging did not replace office visits or phone calls; it was added on top of them. Veterans Health Administration data published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research confirm what primary care doctors already know: More video visits do not cause burnout, but a surge in secure messages does. Primary care physicians take on most of this unpaid, asynchronous work.
The debate is no longer whether telehealth works, but how health systems and payers design clinical workflows and payment models that capture its benefits while respecting its limits. Triage protocols should route behavioral health, medication refills, and routine chronic follow-ups to virtual visits, while sending acute pain and infectious complaints that require point-of-care testing into the clinic. More than a quarter of Medicare beneficiaries, disproportionately older and lower-income patients, lack the broadband or devices needed for video. Cutting payment for phone visits does not save money; it locks out these patients who already face the steepest barriers to care. At the same time, portal messaging is no longer an informal courtesy. It has become a core channel of primary care, so health systems and payers must build dedicated staffing models and fair reimbursement for asynchronous care rather than leaving clinicians to absorb it as unpaid after-hours labor.
The pandemic proved telehealth can reach millions overnight; the task now is to ensure it sharpens clinical judgment, narrows disparities, and supports the clinicians on the other side of the screen. By learning from recent experience and investing in thoughtful policy, telehealth can evolve from a crisis solution into a lasting foundation for equitable, high-quality care.
Timothy Lesaca is a psychiatrist in private practice at New Directions Mental Health in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, with more than forty years of experience treating children, adolescents, and adults across outpatient, inpatient, and community mental health settings. He has published in peer-reviewed and professional venues including the Patient Experience Journal, Psychiatric Times, the Allegheny County Medical Society Bulletin, and other clinical journals, with work addressing topics such as open-access scheduling, Landau-Kleffner syndrome, physician suicide, and the dynamics of contemporary medical practice. His recent writing examines issues of identity, ethical complexity, and patient-clinician relationships in modern health care. Additional information about his clinical practice and professional work is available on his website, timothylesacamd.com. His professional profile also appears on his ResearchGate profile, where further publications and details may be found.


