Is coaching in medical education replacing mentorship?
Walk into any medical school or residency program today and you will find coaching everywhere. There are coaches for Step exams, OSCEs, research productivity, wellness, leadership, residency applications, and even “professional identity.” On the surface, this seems like progress, offering structured support, individualized feedback, and measurable outcomes. But beneath this expansion lies a more uncomfortable question. Are we replacing meaning-making mentorship with episodic, transactional coaching?
Coaching: what it does well
At its …
Is coaching in medical education replacing mentorship?
















